Play the free demo Get the demo's link

Palace Picture House · Programme note

Dickson Experimental Sound Film 1894

A man plays a violin into a giant horn while two others dance: 17 seconds from Edison's laboratory, with a sound recording that waited a century to be matched to it.

By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 6 minute read

In short

The Dickson Experimental Sound Film is a few seconds of film made at Thomas Edison's laboratory in New Jersey in late 1894 or early 1895, by his assistant William Kennedy Laurie Dickson. A man plays a violin into a recording horn while two men dance, and the sound went onto a wax cylinder as it happened. It is described as the earliest surviving film made with live-recorded sound. It was an experiment, never shown commercially in that form, and the cylinder was only matched to the picture again around a century later.

Watch the film

The whole film with its recorded sound: about 18 seconds, in the version synchronised for the Library of Congress. Turn the sound on.

Played from Wikimedia Commons, which hosts this copy as a public-domain work. Nothing is fetched from there until you press play. If it will not play here, it will on their page.

Made by
William Kennedy Laurie Dickson, at Thomas Edison's laboratory; William Heise is named as the cameraman in the usual credits
Filmed
Late 1894 or early 1895: sources differ. Made at the Black Maria studio, West Orange, New Jersey
On screen
A violinist, usually taken to be Dickson himself, playing into a recording horn; two men dancing; a fourth man who crosses behind the horn near the end
Music
A barcarolle from Robert Planquette's operetta Les Cloches de Corneville (1877)
Length
About 17 seconds as restored; some sources say 16. The picture runs 638 frames
Speed
Disputed: Walter Murch and Dickson's own 1895 book say 40 frames a second; the Library of Congress curator Patrick Loughney says 46
What survives
A silent nitrate print, once at the Museum of Modern Art, and the wax cylinder, found broken at the Edison site. The sound was recovered in 1998 and joined to the picture by Murch
Copyright
Public domain: made in the 1890s by a man who died in 1935. The modern synchronised version is the Library of Congress's work and is shown by it

What is on it

Three men and a horn. One plays a violin, bent towards a huge recording horn like the bell of a giant trumpet. Two others waltz round the floor beside him. Near the end a fourth man walks across behind the horn. It lasts about 17 seconds as it is now shown, though some sources say 16.

The tune is a barcarolle from Robert Planquette's operetta Les Cloches de Corneville, first staged in 1877. The violinist is usually taken to be William Kennedy Laurie Dickson, the man who made the film. Walter Murch, who later reunited its sound with its picture, says so, and the cylinder that held the sound bears a label with Dickson's name in a variant spelling. One writer has suggested another player, Charles D'Almaine, but Patrick Loughney of the Library of Congress has rebutted that.

Edison's laboratory

Dickson was born in Brittany in 1860 to a British family, and joined Edison's laboratory in 1883 and became its photographer. Edison conceived a machine that would do "for the Eye what the phonograph does for the Ear", as the idea is usually quoted. Dickson and his team then built it. The camera was the Kinetograph and the peepshow viewer the Kinetoscope.

Who did what is a matter of record, though the record was long told in Edison's favour. Edison filed the early patent caveats and took the credit. Historians now generally say that Dickson did most of the practical work, with colleagues such as William Heise. Gordon Hendricks's book The Edison Motion Picture Myth (1961) argued that the laboratory began work on a film-strip machine much later than Edison and Dickson claimed, and that the date was bent to establish priority. The credit is shared, with the larger share going to Dickson.

The laboratory made its films in the Black Maria at West Orange, New Jersey. It was a tar-paper studio with a roof that opened and a body that could be turned towards the sun. By most accounts it was finished in early 1893, and the National Park Service, which keeps the site, calls it the world's first motion picture studio. The Black Maria's best-known film of the winter of 1894 was Edison Kinetoscopic Record of a Sneeze. It was shot in early January, by the usual account on 7 January, as publicity for a magazine article, and the copyright deposit followed two days later. The Kinetoscope itself opened to the paying public in New York on 14 April 1894.

Picture and phonograph

Edison had wanted pictures and sound together from the start, the eye and the ear. The result was the Kinetophone: a Kinetoscope with a cylinder phonograph. It was introduced in 1895 and about 45 machines are said to have been built. One account says it made no attempt at synchronisation.

The experimental film is the other kind of attempt: picture and sound made together, on purpose. There is no evidence that it was shown in its original form. It seems to have been a laboratory test for the Kinetophone, nothing more.

The cylinder and the print

For decades the picture and the sound lived apart. A silent nitrate print came to the Museum of Modern Art and was copied onto safety film in 1942. The Edison laboratory was given to the National Park Service in 1956. In the early 1960s a cylinder in a canister labelled with Dickson's name was found there. By 1964 it had cracked and a large piece had broken off. Nobody connected it with the film.

That happened in 1998. Loughney and the site's Jerry Fabris had the cylinder repaired and its sound recovered at the Rodgers and Hammerstein Archive of Recorded Sound in New York. The cylinder holds roughly two and a half minutes of sound, against 17 seconds of picture, so the first task was to find which part of the sound belonged to the film. The Library had no equipment for the matching and turned to Walter Murch, the film editor, on the suggestion of the producer Rick Schmidlin. Murch digitised both and tried dozens of sync points before one worked. His work is dated to around 2000. A synchronised version was projected publicly at the Edison site on 1 June 2002.

The speed is disputed. The prints hold 638 frames. Murch, and Dickson's own 1895 book, say the camera ran at 40 frames a second, which gives about 16 seconds. Loughney says 46, which would make the picture shorter than the sound it was set to. Hendricks argued that no Kinetoscope film was shot at that speed.

Two men dancing

The two dancers have given the film a second life. Vito Russo's book The Celluloid Closet (1981) reads it as a gay image, and says the film was called The Gay Brothers. No source has been found for that title, and it is widely repeated without evidence.

Historians make three points. First, "gay" did not generally mean homosexual in the 1890s, which makes the title doubtful on its face. Second, men danced together for many reasons in the period: all-male "stag dances" were standard in the American army and at West Point, and the Black Maria was an all-male workplace. Third, the film's makers left no word about what they meant. The song's lyrics, about life at sea without women, make a joke about that all-male studio more plausible. The film itself cannot settle it.

Why it matters

It is the earliest surviving film with live-recorded sound. Murch calls it the earliest surviving synchronised film and sound, and says it "pushes the threshold of film sound back by a couple of decades". He also notes anecdotal evidence of an earlier attempt in 1891, with no film or image of it found. The Library of Congress added it to the National Film Registry in 2003.

It is not the first talkie. Nobody speaks in it. It was an experiment, never shown commercially in that form, and the match between sound and picture was made by hand a century later. Warner Bros.' The Jazz Singer (1927) is not the first sound film either. The careful claim for it is that it was the first successful synchronised feature with talking, and that is a claim about a feature and about success, not about invention.

It puts a face to a credit. The violinist is usually taken to be Dickson himself, the man historians now credit with most of the work on Edison's camera, playing in the one film that shows what he was after.

On the same programme

Some of these films are rooms you can play

These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.

Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.

Quick answers

What is the Dickson Experimental Sound Film?

A film of about 17 seconds made at Thomas Edison's laboratory by William Kennedy Laurie Dickson, in which a man plays a violin into a recording horn while two men dance. The sound was recorded live on a wax cylinder.

When was the Dickson Experimental Sound Film made?

In late 1894 or early 1895. Sources give both, and no single day is known, which is why its title carries a range of years.

Was the Dickson Experimental Sound Film the first talkie?

No. Nobody speaks in it, it was never shown to the public in this form, and the sound and picture were separate recordings. It is called the earliest surviving film made with live-recorded sound, which is a smaller claim.

Who plays the violin in the Dickson Experimental Sound Film?

Usually Dickson himself. Walter Murch says so, and the cylinder's label bears his name. One writer has suggested another player, Charles D'Almaine, and the Library of Congress curator Patrick Loughney has rebutted that.

How was the sound of the Dickson film recovered?

The wax cylinder was found broken at the Edison laboratory site. In 1998 it was repaired and re-recorded in New York. The film editor Walter Murch then joined the sound to the picture, working with the Library of Congress.

Why is the Dickson film said to show two gay men dancing?

Vito Russo's book The Celluloid Closet described it that way and gave the film a title, The Gay Brothers, for which no source has been found. Historians point out that men commonly danced together in the 1890s for many reasons, and that the film's makers left no such meaning.

Is the Dickson Experimental Sound Film in the National Film Registry?

Yes. The Library of Congress added it in 2003.

Is the Dickson Experimental Sound Film in the public domain?

The film itself was made in the 1890s by a man who died in 1935, so it is out of copyright. The modern synchronisation is the Library of Congress's own work.

Sources and further reading

  1. The Dickson Experimental Sound Film, Wikipedia, for the dating, the frame-rate dispute, the cylinder's history, the restoration and the Celluloid Closet reading
  2. Walter Murch on Reconstructing the Dickson Experimental Sound Film, Spencer Sundell, quoting Murch's own account
  3. The Dickson Experimental Sound Film, DesigningSound.org, 2014, on the cylinder and its re-recording
  4. William Kennedy Dickson, Wikipedia, for his life and his place in Edison's laboratory
  5. Kinetoscope, Wikipedia, for who built what, Hendricks's 1961 book and the Kinetophone
  6. The World's First Motion Picture Studio: Black Maria reopening, National Park Service, Thomas Edison National Historical Park
  7. Edison's Black Maria, Wikipedia, for the building, its turntable and its dates
  8. Fred Ott's Sneeze, Wikipedia, for the January 1894 film and its copyright

The audience is on its way

Now play the films

Reel Trouble is a comedy platformer where every room is a movie set, from 1896 on. The free demo has six rooms, a secret room and a premiere.

Free · Desktop: browser, Windows, Mac, Linux · Played with a keyboard