Palace Picture House · Programme note
The Birth of a Nation 1915
D. W. Griffith's epic is technically important and openly racist: it presents the Ku Klux Klan as heroes, and the protests against it began within weeks.
By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 6 minute read
In short
The Birth of a Nation is a 1915 American silent film directed by D. W. Griffith, based on Thomas Dixon's novel and play The Clansman. It tells the story of the Civil War and Reconstruction from a white Southern point of view, presents the Ku Klux Klan as heroes and Black Americans, many of them white actors in blackface, as a threat. Historians treat it as racist propaganda. It is also a landmark of film technique, which is why film history cannot leave it out. Black protest against it began at once, and answers followed, among them Oscar Micheaux's Within Our Gates (1920).
Watch the film
It is not played on this page: see where to watch it.
Find where to stream, rent or buy it, on JustWatch.
- Original title
- The Clansman, the title of its first public showings; renamed The Birth of a Nation before the New York opening
- Released
- Los Angeles, 8 February 1915 (as The Clansman); New York, early March 1915 (as The Birth of a Nation)
- Made by
- Epoch Producing Co. Producers D. W. Griffith and Harry Aitken. Screenplay Griffith and Frank E. Woods; camera Billy Bitzer; score Joseph Carl Breil
- Source
- Thomas Dixon Jr.'s novel The Clansman (1905) and his stage play of the same name
- Cast
- Lillian Gish, Mae Marsh, Henry B. Walthall, Miriam Cooper, Ralph Lewis, George Siegmann, Walter Long. Many Black characters were played by white actors in blackface
- Filmed
- Southern California from July to October 1914, including the San Fernando Valley, Big Bear Lake and Whittier; US Army engineers advised on the battle scenes
- Length
- Twelve reels, the first American feature of that length that was not a serial; versions run from about 133 to 193 minutes
- Copyright
- Public domain in the United States. Griffith died in 1948. Restorations and recorded scores can have rights of their own
What the film is
The Birth of a Nation is based on The Clansman, a novel of 1905 and a stage play by Thomas Dixon Jr. It follows two families, one Northern and one Southern, through the Civil War and Reconstruction. It tells that history from a white Southern point of view, and it is not a neutral telling.
The film presents the Ku Klux Klan as heroes who restore order. It presents Black Americans as a threat, as ignorant, violent and a danger above all to white women. Many Black characters are played by white actors in blackface. Its picture of Reconstruction follows the school of history associated with William Dunning, which was common in universities at the time and has since been rejected by historians. Historians and critics treat the film as racist propaganda.
How it was made
D. W. Griffith directed, with the cameraman Billy Bitzer, and wrote the script with Frank E. Woods. The producers were Griffith and Harry Aitken. Dixon was reportedly paid $10,000 for the rights to his play, plus a share of the profits. Filming began on 4 July 1914 in Southern California and was done by October. The budget began at about $40,000 and is reported to have passed $100,000. US Army engineers are said to have advised on the battle scenes.
The result ran twelve reels, the first American feature of that length that was not a serial. Versions of it run from about 133 to 193 minutes. It had its own orchestral score by Joseph Carl Breil, played in the larger cinemas.
The craft, and why it cannot be ignored
Griffith did not invent the close-up, the fade-out or crosscutting, but he used them with a command that audiences had not seen. The film has dramatic close-ups, tracking shots, parallel action cut between places, and a staged battle in which hundreds of extras are made to look like thousands. Film historians still teach it for these reasons.
The claims made for it vary. It is often called the first blockbuster, and by one reckoning it was the most successful film shown in New York in the silent era. Careful writers add that the same techniques are what make its message effective. The craft was not separate from the ideas, and a film this skilful and this persuasive is exactly why historians keep it in view.
Release and protest
After trial showings, the film opened in Los Angeles on 8 February 1915 as The Clansman. On 18 February it was shown in the East Room of the White House, for President Woodrow Wilson, his family and guests, as a favour to Dixon. A line is often quoted as Wilson's, that it was "like writing history with lightning". That is disputed. It appears in print only decades later, and a historian who searched the 1915 newspapers cited for it could not find it. What can be said is that Wilson saw the film.
The title was changed before the New York opening in early March 1915. Black Americans and some white liberals protested at once. The NAACP, founded only six years earlier, first sought a ban, and when that gained little support it asked for the worst scenes to be cut. In Boston, William Monroe Trotter led marches and a mass meeting, and there were arrests outside a theatre. Jane Addams was among the white critics.
The campaign had mixed results. Several cities and a number of mayors refused the film, and the censors of Boston and Chicago ordered minor cuts. There was violence at some showings, and in 1916 a white man in Indiana is reported to have murdered a Black teenager after seeing it, though how far the film was the cause is disputed. By the end of 1915, however, it could be shown almost anywhere in the country, and it was a great commercial success.
The Klan
The first Klan, of the late 1860s and 1870s, had no standard costume and did not burn crosses. The white robes and the burning cross that later stood for it come from Dixon's novel and then from the film. In November 1915 William J. Simmons founded a new Klan at Stone Mountain, Georgia, with a burning cross, and when the film reached Atlanta in December his members paraded in robes to the cinema. Historians generally say the film inspired this revival, and the historian John Hope Franklin is reported to have judged that the Klan might not have been reborn without it. The new Klan, a movement of hatred directed at Black Americans, Jews, Catholics and immigrants, stayed small until about 1920.
The answers
Griffith answered his critics with Intolerance (1916), a longer film in four parallel stories. By most accounts he saw it as a rebuttal to people he thought intolerant themselves, not as an apology.
The more important answers came from Black filmmakers. Oscar Micheaux's Within Our Gates (1920) is widely read as a reply, with lynching scenes that show what Black Americans knew and many white Northerners would not believe. Chicago's censors rejected it at first, and it was long thought lost until a copy turned up in Spain in 1979. It was added to the National Film Registry in 1992, the year in which The Birth of a Nation was added too.
Why it matters
It shows what film can do. A film made with new skill could shape how a country saw its own past, and it did.
It cannot be taught as technique alone. Its methods and its message arrive together, and the film's racism is part of its history, not a footnote to it.
It began a long argument about film and harm. The protests of 1915 are often counted among the first mass Black protest movements of the twentieth century, and they raised questions about censorship and responsibility that are still argued.
It was answered. Micheaux and other Black filmmakers made their own pictures of American life, and their work is as much a part of the story as Griffith's.
On the same programme
Some of these films are rooms you can play
These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.
-
1896
Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat
Our room: Arrival of the Pain
-
1902
A Trip to the Moon
Our room: A Trip to the Moan
-
1923
Safety Last!
Our room: Safety Second
Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.
Quick answers
Is The Birth of a Nation racist?
Yes. It presents the Ku Klux Klan as heroic and Black Americans as dangerous, and many Black characters are played by white actors in blackface. Historians treat it as racist propaganda, and its image of Reconstruction follows what is now called the Dunning School, a view historians have since rejected.
What is The Birth of a Nation about?
It follows two families, one Northern and one Southern, through the American Civil War and Reconstruction. The story is told from a white Southern view and ends with the Klan restoring white rule.
Why is The Birth of a Nation important in film history?
Griffith used close-ups, crosscutting, tracking shots and a staged battle on a scale that audiences had not seen, with an orchestral score written for it. Many critics hold that this craft and the film's ideas cannot be separated.
Did Woodrow Wilson say it was like writing history with lightning?
That is disputed. Wilson did see the film at the White House in February 1915, but the historian Mark Benbow, who searched the 1915 newspapers cited for the famous line, could not find it there.
Did The Birth of a Nation revive the Ku Klux Klan?
Historians generally say it inspired the revival. In late 1915 William J. Simmons founded the new Klan at Stone Mountain, Georgia, and the film's costumes and burning cross became its imagery.
How did Black Americans respond to The Birth of a Nation?
The NAACP and others campaigned for bans or cuts, and William Monroe Trotter led protests in Boston. Oscar Micheaux answered the film with Within Our Gates in 1920.
Was The Birth of a Nation banned?
Some cities and states refused it and several mayors banned it in 1915, but by the end of that year it could be shown almost anywhere in the United States, with only minor cuts in a few places.
Is The Birth of a Nation in the public domain?
It is in the public domain in the United States. Griffith died in 1948. Restorations and recorded scores can have rights of their own.
Sources and further reading
- The Birth of a Nation, Wikipedia: production, release, protests, techniques and copyright, with the points given here as reported
- Birth of a Quotation: Woodrow Wilson and "Like Writing History with Lightning", Mark E. Benbow, Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, 2010
- 100 years ago the first White House film screening sparked nationwide protests, The Conversation, 2015
- Ku Klux Klan, Wikipedia: the second Klan and its founding in 1915
- Question of the Month, August 2012, Jim Crow Museum, Ferris State University, on the NAACP's campaign
- Within Our Gates, Wikipedia: Oscar Micheaux's 1920 film, its censorship and its rediscovery
- Intolerance (film), Wikipedia: Griffith's 1916 film and its relation to the criticism
