Play the free demo Get the demo's link

Palace Picture House · Programme note

Intolerance 1916

After the storm over The Birth of a Nation, Griffith built Babylon in Hollywood, cut four ages together, and lost the argument with the box office.

By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 6 minute read

In short

Intolerance is a 1916 American silent epic written and directed by D. W. Griffith, who made it straight after The Birth of a Nation. It cuts between four stories, the fall of Babylon, the last days of Christ, the St Bartholomew's Day massacre and a modern tale of a strike and a wrongful sentence, with a woman rocking a cradle between them. Its Babylon set was one of the largest ever built for a film. It struggled at the box office, though how badly is disputed, and it was a lasting influence on editing, not least in the Soviet Union.

Watch the film

The whole film: 167 minutes, silent, with its tints and no music.

Played from Wikimedia Commons, which hosts this copy as a public-domain work. Nothing is fetched from there until you press play. If it will not play here, it will on their page.

Premiere
5 September 1916, Liberty Theatre, New York. A preview was held in Riverside, California, on 5 August 1916
Made by
Written and directed by D. W. Griffith. Photographed by G. W. (Billy) Bitzer. Intertitles credited to Anita Loos
Cast
Lillian Gish (the woman who rocks the cradle), Mae Marsh (the Dear One), Robert Harron (the Boy), Constance Talmadge (the Mountain Girl and Marguerite of Valois), Howard Gaye (the Nazarene), Alfred Paget (Belshazzar), George Siegmann (Cyrus)
Company and cost
Griffith's own Wark Producing Corporation. The cost is given as about $386,000 by one account and close to $2 million by others; sources differ
Length
About 210 minutes on release, according to the BFI and others. Griffith kept recutting it, and no single version is definitive; most surviving prints run shorter
Format
35 mm, black and white, silent, with some scenes hand-tinted. Subtitled Love's Struggle Throughout the Ages
Honours
Selected for the US National Film Registry in 1989, the first year of selection. 225th in the 2022 Sight and Sound critics' poll
Copyright
In the public domain in the United States, as a work published in 1916: Duke's Center for the Study of the Public Domain gives a 95-year term for works published before 1978. Griffith died in 1948. No free copy is linked here

The answer to the critics

D. W. Griffith had a hit and a scandal in The Birth of a Nation (1915), a film that glorified the Ku Klux Klan and was built on racist stereotypes. The NAACP and others protested it, and in 1915 one New York paper accused Griffith of fomenting race antipathy. The film also filled cinemas for months and made him the means to do whatever he liked next.

What he liked was Intolerance. Griffith never explained its origins clearly. By one account he began with a small contemporary story, The Mother and the Law, about a young couple and a strike, which grew from a modest six reels into fourteen. Sources say he presented the finished film as a rebuttal to his critics, whom he thought intolerant. The Library of Congress essay calls it in part a thinly veiled indictment of the people who had attacked The Birth of a Nation. Historians do not read it as an apology. The film is about the persecution of the innocent, made by a man who had just been accused of persecuting others.

Four stories and a cradle

The film runs four stories at once. In Babylon in 539 BC, the Mountain Girl fights for the city that Persia is about to take. In Judea around AD 27 comes the last part of the life of Christ, the shortest strand. In France in 1572 the St Bartholomew's Day massacre falls on a pair of lovers. In the modern story, set about 1914, a strike is crushed, and a young man is wrongly convicted and sentenced to hang.

Griffith cuts between them with growing speed, and the Library of Congress essay counts more than fifty transitions. The link is a woman, Lillian Gish, rocking a cradle, a picture of the generations passing. It is not a plot device, and some viewers have found the whole structure hard to follow. He had cut several stories around one theme before, in short films, but never on this scale. He worked without a script, and by the essay's account only a handful of his crew knew that one film, not four, was being made.

Babylon on Sunset Boulevard

The Babylon set made the film's name. It stood on Sunset Boulevard, at its junction with Hollywood Boulevard, where the Vista Theatre now stands. It was crowded with huge elephant statues, and the Library of Congress essay mentions elephant handlers among the staff. Sources differ on its height: the essay says the walls towered 160 feet over the street, while other accounts give 300 feet. Thousands of extras were carried out each day by streetcar to play the Persian army.

The set was not built to last. By one account Griffith could not afford to pull it down, and it was used again for Hearts of the World (1918). The same account says the fire department found the crumbling remains a hazard and had them razed in 1919, about three years after the film opened. Another account, citing a 1917 trade paper, says the sets were destroyed two years after they were built.

The money and the box office

The figures are disputed. One figure for the budget is $385,907, from the film's own accounts; others put the cost close to $2 million, with $250,000 for the Belshazzar feast alone. It gives about $1.75 million in rentals and calls the picture of a ruinous flop a myth born of the larger budget figure. Other writers say it did poorly at the box office, and the BFI calls it a commercial failure.

The Library of Congress essay takes a middle line. It says Griffith struggled with the film's financial burden and its disappointing reception for the rest of his career, and that it was not the career-ending disaster of legend: Broken Blossoms (1919) and Way Down East (1920) were among his most successful films. A Silent Era entry adds that he was still paying off debts from the production until 1923.

Reception and recutting

It opened at the Liberty Theatre in New York on 5 September 1916, after a preview in Riverside, California, a month earlier. It ran about three and a half hours. Reviews were enthusiastic, but many viewers found it spectacular and baffling. Griffith went on cutting it, for foreign audiences and for revivals, and no version is final.

In late 1918 he cut the original negative into two separate features, released in 1919: The Mother and the Law, the modern story, and The Fall of Babylon, the ancient one. Kevin Brownlow notes that in the first Griffith softened the National Guard's actions during the First Red Scare. The 1989 reconstruction by the Museum of Modern Art runs about twenty minutes longer than any version Griffith himself showed, which has made it controversial.

Why it matters

It made cross-cutting a theme as well as a technique. The film uses cutting to compare whole ages, and the Library of Congress essay says it opened the world's eyes to the power of a more complex film grammar.

The Soviet editors took it seriously. One account says Lenin valued it as a model of editing and narrative for propaganda. Others call Griffith the artistic father of Eisenstein and Pudovkin, and trace the Odessa Steps sequence of Battleship Potemkin (1925) to the Babylon sequences. More cautious accounts say only that it was enormously influential among European and Soviet filmmakers.

It is a lesson in how a film's reputation is made. A failure on release, it was later ranked among the most influential films ever made, and it was among the first films selected for the National Film Registry, in 1989.

It shows the man behind it. A plea against intolerance came from the maker of The Birth of a Nation, and the film is often read with that in mind.

On the same programme

Some of these films are rooms you can play

These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.

Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.

Quick answers

What is Intolerance (1916) about?

Four stories of intolerance are intercut: the fall of Babylon to the Persians, the last days of Christ, the St Bartholomew's Day massacre in France in 1572, and a modern American story of a strike and a young man wrongly sentenced to hang. A woman rocking a cradle links them.

Why did D. W. Griffith make Intolerance?

It followed The Birth of a Nation (1915), which was condemned for its racist stereotypes and its glorifying of the Ku Klux Klan. Griffith presented the new film as an answer to those critics, whom he called intolerant. Historians read it in part as a defence against them, not an apology.

How long is Intolerance?

About 210 minutes on its release in 1916. Griffith cut and recut it for years, so versions differ. Many surviving prints are shorter, and a 1989 reconstruction runs to roughly twenty minutes more than any version Griffith himself showed.

How much did Intolerance cost, and did it lose money?

Sources disagree. One account gives a budget of about $386,000; others say close to $2 million. By one account it earned about $1.75 million in rentals and the idea of a ruinous flop is a myth; the BFI calls it a commercial failure.

Where was the Babylon set in Intolerance?

On Sunset Boulevard in Hollywood, where it is said to have stood at Hollywood Boulevard, on the site where the Vista Theatre now stands. It was torn down in 1919 on the fire department's orders, by one account.

What are The Mother and the Law and The Fall of Babylon?

Two separate features Griffith cut from the negative of Intolerance in 1918 and 1919. The first is the modern story, the second the Babylon story.

Did Intolerance influence Soviet cinema?

By most accounts, yes. Writers describe Griffith as an artistic forebear of Eisenstein and Pudovkin, and one account says Lenin valued the film as a model of editing for propaganda. The Odessa Steps sequence of Battleship Potemkin (1925) is often traced back to it.

Is Intolerance in the public domain?

In the United States, yes. It was published in 1916, and works published before 1978 are protected for 95 years, a term long since over. Rules elsewhere differ, so check before you reuse a print or its score.

Sources and further reading

  1. Intolerance (film), Wikipedia, for the structure, the budget and box-office figures, the later releases and the 1989 Registry selection
  2. Intolerance Babylon set, Wikipedia, on the set's site, its elephants and its demolition
  3. Intolerance, Benjamin Schrom, essay for the Library of Congress National Film Registry, 2007
  4. Intolerance (1916), British Film Institute, film page
  5. Intolerance (1916), Silent Era, Progressive Silent Film List, on the premiere, the company and the 1918 recutting
  6. Museum of Intolerance, Cinemontage, on the film's influence on Soviet filmmakers
  7. Public Domain Day: Frequently Asked Questions, Duke Center for the Study of the Public Domain, 2019

The audience is on its way

Now play the films

Reel Trouble is a comedy platformer where every room is a movie set, from 1896 on. The free demo has six rooms, a secret room and a premiere.

Free · Desktop: browser, Windows, Mac, Linux · Played with a keyboard