Play the free demo Get the demo's link

Palace Picture House · Programme note

Within Our Gates 1920

A South Dakota homesteader turned novelist put a lynching on screen months after the Red Summer of 1919. One print survived, in Spain, under another name.

By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 6 minute read

In short

Within Our Gates is an American silent film of 1920, written, produced and directed by Oscar Micheaux, with Evelyn Preer as Sylvia Landry, a teacher raising money to save a school for Black children. A long flashback intercuts a lynching with a white man's attempt to rape her, and the film is generally read as a response to The Birth of a Nation. Chicago's censors held it up for two months, in a city that had suffered a race riot the summer before. Long thought lost, it survives in a single print found in Spain as La Negra, and is usually described as the oldest known surviving feature by an African American director.

Watch the film

The film as it survives: 80 minutes, silent, from the Library of Congress's copy. It shows a lynching and an attempted rape.

Played from Wikimedia Commons, which hosts this copy as a public-domain work. Nothing is fetched from there until you press play. If it will not play here, it will on their page.

Released
Chicago, January 1920; 12 January is the date usually given. Later showings ran in differently cut versions
Made by
Written, produced and directed by Oscar Micheaux for the Micheaux Book & Film Company
Cast
Evelyn Preer (Sylvia Landry), Charles D. Lucas (Dr Vivian), Floy Clements (Alma Prichard), William Starks (Jasper Landry), Mattie Edwards (his wife), E. G. Tatum (Efrem), Grant Gorman (Armand Gridlestone)
Filmed
1919, in borrowed homes and on Chicago streets, on a very low budget; finished by late 1919
Length
Advertised at 8,000 feet. The surviving print is under 6,000 feet, 79 to 83 minutes depending on the speed
Format
Silent, 35 mm, black and white. Four original English titles survive; the rest are modern reconstructions from the Spanish
Preservation
Added to the US National Film Registry in 1992. Restored by the Library of Congress in 1993 from the Madrid print
Copyright
Public domain in the United States, its home country. Recorded scores added to modern copies can have rights of their own

The story

Sylvia Landry (Evelyn Preer), a young Black woman from the South, loses the man she means to marry to a scheme of her cousin Alma's. She goes home to teach at Piney Woods, a rural school for Black children that faces closure, and travels north to raise $5,000. In Boston she meets Dr Vivian. A car hits her as she saves a child, and its owner, the philanthropist Elena Warwick, gives $50,000. Alma then tells Dr Vivian about Sylvia's past, in a long flashback, and at the end the two marry.

Homesteader, novelist, film-maker

Oscar Micheaux was born in Metropolis, Illinois, in 1884, to parents born enslaved in Kentucky. After three years as a Pullman porter he went to South Dakota in 1904 for a land lottery on the Rosebud Reservation. He did not win, bought a relinquished homestead, and later lost his crops to drought.

He turned this into two novels, The Conquest (1913) and The Homesteader (1917), which he published himself and sold around the region. Talks with the Lincoln Motion Picture Company over filming the second failed on the question of control, and in 1919 he filmed it himself. He paid as he had paid for his books, in advance, selling stock in his company.

The usual channels of distribution were closed to him, so he used his own Micheaux Book & Film Company. Within Our Gates, his second film, was shot in borrowed homes and on Chicago streets, by later accounts seldom with more than one take. He made about forty features, going bankrupt in 1928 and relying on white backers for his sound films.

Evelyn Preer had made her debut in The Homesteader, and Micheaux promoted her as his leading actress. She starred in eight of his silents that are now lost, and died in 1932, aged 36.

Two months with the censors

The film was made during what became known as the Red Summer: between April and October 1919 more than twenty-five race riots broke out across the United States. In Chicago's, that July, 23 African Americans and 15 white people died. Micheaux submitted his film to the city's Board of Censors in December, and it was rejected for its graphic display of lynching, for fear of another riot. The Chicago Defender reported the debate:

Those who reasoned with the spectacle of last July in Chicago ever before them, declared the showing pre-eminently dangerous.

The Chicago Defender, quoted by Scott Simmon

By one account a second screening, for the press, politicians and prominent Black Chicagoans, won a permit. The board "stalled for two months before finally approving the film", writes the historian W. Fitzhugh Brundage. It opened that January, on the 12th by the date usually given, but not whole. One account has the censors enforcing cuts of 1,200 feet, more than a reel, and the Defender promised a later showing "without the cuts which were made before its initial presentation".

The cuts varied by city. Officials in Omaha, New Orleans and elsewhere blocked screenings or demanded changes, and Micheaux edited several versions himself. Some Black activists protested too, and a theatre owner in Shreveport called it "a very dangerous picture to show in the south". In Chicago it drew large crowds.

The flashback, and Griffith

Sylvia was raised by Jasper Landry, a Black sharecropper, and his wife. A poor white man shoots Philip Gridlestone, who has cheated and insulted him, and Efrem, a Black servant, falsely names Landry as the killer. A white mob hunts the family and lynches Landry and his wife. Efrem is lynched too, offscreen.

Micheaux intercuts the lynching with an attempted rape: Armand Gridlestone, a white man, attacks Sylvia. The film reveals that he is her father. Gerald R. Butters Jr. calls the lynching sequence "the most remarkable in African American silent film".

The pairing is the argument. The usual white defence of lynching was that it punished Black men for alleged assaults on white women. Here the attacker is a privileged, apparently respectable white man. "In Micheaux's hands lynching and rape were evidence of white, not black, barbarism," Brundage writes. Butters cites Jane Gaines's bleaker view, that the crosscutting "placed the contemporary African American spectators in a totally hopeless position".

Critics generally read the film as a response to D. W. Griffith's The Birth of a Nation (1915). Micheaux never said so in public, Butters notes, but the climax is built like Griffith's, with a white mob threatening Black characters where Griffith has Black soldiers threatening white ones.

Nor is Micheaux a comfortable hero. The historian Scott Simmon calls Efrem and the preacher Old Ned race traitors, the film's most controversial creations. Micheaux, Brundage writes, "embraced and proselytized the era's 'up by the boot straps' dogma", and "did not shy away from acknowledging those blacks whose behavior, he believed, contributed to stereotypes". The educated characters are light-skinned and the poor ones dark.

Found in Spain as La Negra

For decades the film was thought lost. A single print survived at the Filmoteca Española in Madrid, titled La Negra (The Black Woman). Sources differ on the discovery. Simmon and Brundage put it in the 1970s, Simmon crediting the historian Thomas Cripps. The George Eastman Museum dates the find to 1990, the year Yale's notes give for the print's return to the Library of Congress.

The Library restored it in 1993, a year after it joined the National Film Registry. A brief sequence in the middle is gone. A Spanish distributor had replaced the English intertitles, and only four survive, one frame each. Simmon, who supervised the work, translated the rest back with Alex Vargas, borrowing the diction of Micheaux's books and of his Body and Soul. No record of the originals exists, so these titles only approximate them.

Advertised as "8000 feet of sensational realism", the print runs under 6,000 feet, which suggests that about 30 minutes are missing.

Why it matters

It is the oldest known surviving feature by an African American director. That is the careful form: Simmon writes "the earliest surviving feature film by an African American". The Homesteader came first and is lost. Only three of Micheaux's silents survive.

It put lynching on screen from the side of those it was done to. Micheaux released it, Butters notes, in the same week the NAACP announced its figures on the 1919 lynchings of Black veterans.

Its fate is part of its history. Griffith's film entered the histories of cinema while this one vanished for decades. Brundage counts that elevation of Griffith among the "telling illustrations of the politics of race and power".

On the same programme

Some of these films are rooms you can play

These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.

Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.

Quick answers

What is Within Our Gates about?

Sylvia Landry, a young Black teacher, goes north to raise money for a rural school for Black children in the South. A long flashback then tells her past: the lynching of the couple who raised her, and an attempted rape by a white man who proves to be her father.

Who was Oscar Micheaux?

An American novelist, producer and director (1884 to 1951). He homesteaded in South Dakota, published and sold his own novels, and made about forty features, the early ones paid for by selling stock in his company. His first film, The Homesteader (1919), is lost.

Why was Within Our Gates censored?

Chicago's Board of Censors first rejected it in December 1919 over its lynching scenes, fearing trouble in a city that had suffered a race riot that July. It held the film up for about two months. Cuts were made in Chicago and elsewhere, and they varied from city to city.

Is Within Our Gates a response to The Birth of a Nation?

It is generally read as one. Its climax is built like the climax of Griffith's 1915 film, with a white mob and a white rapist where Griffith has Black ones. Micheaux is not known to have said so publicly.

Is Within Our Gates the oldest surviving film by an African American director?

It is usually described as the oldest known surviving feature by an African American director. Micheaux's first feature, The Homesteader (1919), came a year earlier but is lost.

Where was Within Our Gates found?

In the Filmoteca Española in Madrid, as a single print titled La Negra. The historian Thomas Cripps is credited with finding it in the late 1970s; other accounts date the discovery to 1990, the year the print is said to have reached the Library of Congress.

Are the intertitles in Within Our Gates original?

Only four are. A Spanish distributor had replaced the English titles, and for the Library of Congress restoration the rest were translated back into English, in language drawn from Micheaux's other work. They only approximate what he wrote.

Is Within Our Gates in the public domain?

Yes, in the United States, where it was made in 1920. Wikimedia Commons hosts a copy, taken from the Library of Congress, as public domain there. Recorded scores added to modern copies can have rights of their own.

Sources and further reading

  1. Within Our Gates, Scott Simmon, San Francisco Silent Film Festival, 2016 programme essay, by the historian who supervised the reconstruction
  2. Why I'll Watch Oscar Micheaux's Within Our Gates Until I Wear It Out, W. Fitzhugh Brundage, Perspectives on History, American Historical Association, September 2010
  3. From Homestead to Lynch Mob: Portrayals of Black Masculinity in Oscar Micheaux's Within Our Gates, Gerald R. Butters Jr., Journal for MultiMedia History
  4. Film Notes: Within Our Gates, Brian Meacham, Yale University Library, 2015
  5. Within Our Gates, George Eastman Museum, screening notes
  6. Oscar Micheaux, US National Park Service, on his life and homestead
  7. Within Our Gates (1920), Jeff Stafford, Turner Classic Movies, 2004
  8. Within Our Gates, USA 1920, Early & Silent Film, 2018, on the Chicago cuts
  9. File: Within Our Gates HQ.webm, Wikimedia Commons, on the copy's source and its status in the United States
  10. Within Our Gates, Wikipedia, with its articles on Oscar Micheaux and Evelyn Preer: the plot, the cast and the points given here as reported

The audience is on its way

Now play the films

Reel Trouble is a comedy platformer where every room is a movie set, from 1896 on. The free demo has six rooms, a secret room and a premiere.

Free · Desktop: browser, Windows, Mac, Linux · Played with a keyboard