Play the free demo Get the demo's link

Palace Picture House · Programme note

London After Midnight 1927

Tod Browning's vampire mystery was a hit in 1927, and its last known print is said to have burned in 1965. No copy is known to survive.

By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 6 minute read

In short

London After Midnight is an American silent horror mystery of 1927, directed by Tod Browning for MGM, in which Lon Chaney plays a Scotland Yard inspector and, in disguise, a sharp-toothed vampire in a tall hat. It made a handsome profit, and Browning remade it with sound in 1935 as Mark of the Vampire. Its last known print is said to have been lost in an MGM vault fire in 1965, and no copy is known today. What survives is the script, publicity stills and a 2002 reconstruction built from them, which is a new work and not the film.

Watch the film

There is no clean free copy to play or link to here.

London After Midnight

1927

Released
3 December 1927, by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer
Made by
MGM. Director and story Tod Browning; scenario Waldemar Young; titles Joseph W. Farnham; camera Merritt B. Gerstad; sets Cedric Gibbons; Irving Thalberg credited as producer
Cast
Lon Chaney (Inspector Burke and the "Man in the Beaver Hat"), Marceline Day, Conrad Nagel, Henry B. Walthall, Polly Moran
Source
An original story by Browning, said to have been called "The Hypnotist"
Length
About 69 minutes as released; the 2002 reconstruction runs about 45 minutes
Format
Silent, black and white, English intertitles
Status
Lost. The last known print is said to have been destroyed in the MGM vault fire of 1965; no copy is known to survive
Copyright
Entered the US public domain on 1 January 2023, with the other 1927 films (Duke's Center for the Study of the Public Domain lists it as "now a lost film"). The 2002 reconstruction and its score are separate work, with rights of their own

The story

Nobody can watch London After Midnight as it was shown, so its plot comes from the script, the synopses and the surviving stills. Here is how they tell it, twist included.

In a London house, Roger Balfour is found dead, and the case is closed as a suicide. Five years later the house is empty, and figures that look like vampires are seen in it: a figure in a beaver hat with a fixed stare and a mouthful of sharpened teeth. Scotland Yard sends Inspector Burke, played by Lon Chaney. He suspects that Balfour was murdered, and he hypnotises Sir James Hamlin, a friend of the household, into acting out the night of the death. Sir James is the murderer, by the usual summary, and he faked the suicide so that he could marry Lucille Balfour.

The twist is that the vampires were never real. Burke staged the haunting to trap his man, and Chaney, by most accounts, played both the inspector and the vampire in the beaver hat. The film leans on a well-worn device of the stage mystery: the supernatural is a hoax, and the detective is the hoaxer.

Who made it

Tod Browning wrote the story, which he is said to have first called "The Hypnotist", and directed it. Waldemar Young wrote the scenario and Joseph W. Farnham the titles. Irving Thalberg is credited as producer. Marceline Day plays Lucille, Conrad Nagel her suitor and Henry B. Walthall Sir James.

MGM's records, as reported, give a cost of about $152,000 and rentals of about $1,004,000, a profit of some $540,000. The reviews were mixed. The New York Times called the story somewhat incoherent, and Harrison's Reports thought it nonsensical, while other papers liked it. The takings counted for more, and MGM is said to have renewed Browning's contract.

The Man in the Beaver Hat

The film is remembered for one face. Chaney, the actor who made a trade of his own disguises, gave the false vampire a tall beaver hat, a grin of tiny sharpened teeth and an unblinking stare. The teeth are well documented. The eyes are less certain: one account has Chaney wearing wire fittings, like monocles, to pull his eyes wide, and the story is repeated everywhere, but it is hard to check, because the film that would show it is gone. Treat it as a legend that fits the face in the stills.

The same stills made the character famous long after the film vanished. For many people the Man in the Beaver Hat is simply the way a silent vampire looks.

The lost print

MGM kept its silent negatives and prints in a vault at its Culver City lot. A studio inventory of 1955 lists a print of London After Midnight in Vault 7, and the historians William K. Everson and David Bradley said they had seen the film in the early 1950s. Then came the fire. Most accounts say that on 10 August 1965 an electrical fault set off a blaze that destroyed Vault 7 and hundreds of films with it, and with them the last known print.

That is the whole of the evidence for the loss, and it is not proof that no copy exists anywhere. But decades of searching have found none, and the film now has the standing of a holy grail among collectors. The film is described as long lost, and no print has been shown.

The Hyde Park murder

The film has a dark footnote. On 23 October 1928 a policeman found an out-of-work man from North Wales, Robert Williams, lying hurt by a razor in Hyde Park, London, beside the body of a woman, Julia Mangan. At his trial he is said to have described seeing a face before the attack, and to have named it as the face Chaney wore in London After Midnight. The film is said to have been mentioned in court, and a judge to have commented on whether it might have influenced him.

Take the rest with care. The first jury could not agree, a second convicted him in January 1929, and the Home Secretary soon reprieved him on medical evidence that he was insane. The accounts that link the film to his words rely on press reports, and they differ. What is certain is the crime. That a film caused it is a story, and no court said so.

The remake and the reconstruction

Browning remade the film as Mark of the Vampire, released on 26 April 1935 with sound. Lionel Barrymore stands in for Chaney as the hypnotist Professor Zelen, and Bela Lugosi, fresh from Dracula, plays Count Mora. The plot follows the old one: the vampires are hired actors, and the murderer is tricked into re-enacting his crime. It runs about an hour, shorter than the film it copies, and it is the nearest thing to a working copy of the story.

In 2002 Turner Classic Movies had Rick Schmidlin put together a reconstruction of about 45 minutes. He used the script and surviving production stills, with added camera movement. It is a respectable piece of work and a new one: it is not Browning's cutting, and nobody should mistake it for a found print.

Why it matters

It is the standard case of a lost film. Historians often cite it as the most sought-after lost film of the silent era, partly for its star and partly because it was lost late, in a studio's own vault, when people knew exactly what they were losing.

It shows what Chaney could do with a face. The make-up is the film's legacy, and the image outlived the picture. Later horror borrowed the hat, the grin and the stare.

It fed the later vampire films. Browning went on to direct Dracula in 1931, and then remade this story with his Dracula star. The hoax-vampire plot became a stock device of the mystery.

It is free to use, and mostly missing. Since 1 January 2023 the film is in the United States public domain, as its fellow 1927 releases are, and there is nothing to copy. The loss is also a reminder that most silent films did not survive.

On the same programme

Some of these films are rooms you can play

These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.

Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.

Quick answers

Is London After Midnight a lost film?

Yes. No print is known to survive. The last known copy is said to have been destroyed in the MGM vault fire of 1965, most accounts say.

What happened to London After Midnight?

MGM kept the negative and a print in its vaults. A studio inventory of 1955 lists a print in Vault 7, and the fire that destroyed that vault in 1965 is blamed for the loss of the last known copy.

What is London After Midnight about?

A man is found dead in his London house and the case is called suicide. Five years later, strange figures haunt the empty house, and a Scotland Yard inspector, played by Lon Chaney, investigates. The vampires turn out to be a trick to catch a murderer.

Was London After Midnight a vampire film?

In appearance, yes: Chaney's figure has sharpened teeth, a tall hat and a fixed stare. But the film is a murder mystery, and the vampires are not real. The twist is that the inspector himself plays the vampire.

Is there a remake of London After Midnight?

Yes. Tod Browning remade it as Mark of the Vampire, released by MGM on 26 April 1935, with Lionel Barrymore and Bela Lugosi in the parts Chaney had played.

Did London After Midnight cause a real murder?

No. In 1928 a man accused of killing a woman in Hyde Park is said to have described seeing Chaney's face from the film, and the film was talked of at his trial. Reports of his words differ, and no court found that a film caused the crime.

Can you watch London After Midnight?

Not the film itself. You can watch a 2002 reconstruction made for Turner Classic Movies from the script and production stills, which was issued on a DVD set. It is a new work, not a rediscovered print.

Is London After Midnight in the public domain?

In the United States, yes: Duke's Center for the Study of the Public Domain lists it among the 1927 films that entered the public domain on 1 January 2023. Reconstructions and recorded scores are separate work, and a character's look is a separate matter from a film's copyright.

Sources and further reading

  1. London After Midnight (film), Wikipedia: credits, release, plot, budget and rentals, the 1955 inventory, the reconstruction
  2. Why Lon Chaney's London After Midnight Is the Holy Grail of Lost Cinema, SlashFilm: the make-up, the fire of 10 August 1965, the 2002 reconstruction
  3. Mark of the Vampire, Wikipedia: the 1935 remake, its cast and its twist
  4. The Lost Movie London After Midnight and the Brutal Murder of Julia Mangan in 1928, Flashbak: the Hyde Park case and the trials
  5. London After Midnight: the most sought-after lost movie in cinema history, Far Out Magazine: the story, the fire, the folklore
  6. Public Domain Day 2023, Duke Center for the Study of the Public Domain: the 1927 films entering the public domain
  7. 2023 public domain debuts: Sherlock Holmes, Metropolis, Bessie Smith, Faulkner and many more, KQED, on the 1927 works and the lost films among them

The audience is on its way

Now play the films

Reel Trouble is a comedy platformer where every room is a movie set, from 1896 on. The free demo has six rooms, a secret room and a premiere.

Free · Desktop: browser, Windows, Mac, Linux · Played with a keyboard