Play the free demo Get the demo's link

Palace Picture House · Programme note

The Man Who Laughs 1928

Paul Leni's Universal film gave Conrad Veidt a face fixed in a grin, and a comic-book villain later borrowed it.

By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 6 minute read

In short

The Man Who Laughs is an American silent film of 1928, directed by Paul Leni for Universal and based on Victor Hugo's novel of 1869. Conrad Veidt plays Gwynplaine, a boy whose mouth was cut into a permanent grin by child-traders and who grows up to be a fairground star, with Mary Philbin as the blind girl he loves. It was released with a synchronised score and sound effects but no spoken dialogue. Reviews at the time were mixed, but its design fed Universal's horror films of the 1930s, and the creators of the Joker later pointed to a photograph of Veidt in the part.

Watch the film

It is not played on this page: see where to watch it.

The Man Who Laughs

1928

Where to watch it (opens in a new tab) on JustWatch

Find where to stream, rent or buy it, on JustWatch.

Original title
The Man Who Laughs, from Victor Hugo's L'Homme qui rit (1869)
Released
New York premiere on 27 April 1928 at the Central Theatre; general release in the United States on 4 November 1928
Made by
Universal Pictures, produced by Carl Laemmle. Director Paul Leni; sets Charles D. Hall; camera Gilbert Warrenton
Cast
Conrad Veidt (Gwynplaine), Mary Philbin (Dea), Olga Baclanova (Josiana)
Make-up
Credited to Jack Pierce, Universal's head make-up artist, who is also said to have devised the mouthpiece
Length
About 110 minutes in ten reels (the length given for the sound version)
Format
Black and white, 35 mm; intertitles; a synchronised score and sound effects, no spoken dialogue
Copyright
Public domain in the United States since 1 January 2024, as Duke's Center for the Study of the Public Domain lists it. Leni died in 1929. Restorations and recorded scores have rights of their own

The story

The film is set in England in the late seventeenth century. A boy, abandoned in a snowstorm, finds a baby girl and takes her to Ursus, a wandering showman who takes both in. The boy's mouth is fixed in a wide grin. As the story is told, he is Gwynplaine, the son of a nobleman who made an enemy of King James II. The king had the child sold to the comprachicos, a band that buys children and disfigures them, and they cut his face into a smile.

That is the premise, and the film does not look away from it. A child was mutilated to punish his father, and the smile is the scar. Grown up, Gwynplaine earns his living by it, as the star of Ursus's fairground show, where audiences roar at a man who cannot stop laughing. The baby, Dea, has grown up blind and loves him without seeing his face. The plot then lifts him into the court and the House of Lords, among people who find his face funnier or more useful than he does, before the lovers are reunited.

Hugo's novel

Victor Hugo published L'Homme qui rit in 1869, seven years after Les Misérables. It was not one of his great popular successes. The comprachicos are his invention, by one account, a trade of child-buyers who turn children into begging attractions or exhibits. The book uses its monster to attack a society in which the powerful can do such things and be rewarded for them.

The film keeps the central wound and the blind girl, and gives the story a happier ending than the novel's, where Dea dies and Gwynplaine drowns himself. Writers who have compared the two find the film is closer to a romance and political satire than to horror, even if the pictures often say otherwise.

Veidt and the grin

Conrad Veidt had been Cesare, the somnambulist, in The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920), and he had moved to Beverly Hills in 1926. In this film he plays Gwynplaine, and briefly the father. The effect of the grin was made in his mouth. By most accounts he wore false teeth and other apparatus that held the corners of his mouth up and made it difficult to speak. Jack Pierce, then Universal's head make-up artist, is credited with the look, and several writers say he devised the mouthpiece, which was painful to wear. The details come from secondary accounts, not from a studio record, and sources differ on how it was built.

What Veidt did with the rest of his face is the reason the film is still shown. With the mouth fixed, he plays Gwynplaine's shame and tenderness through his eyes and shoulders. One account says extras applauded his work in the House of Lords scene.

Paul Leni and Universal

Universal's founder Carl Laemmle brought Paul Leni from Berlin. Born in Stuttgart in 1885, Leni had designed sets and costumes for German directors from 1913, and directed Waxworks (1924), a film often counted among the works of German expressionism. He went to Hollywood in 1927 and made The Cat and the Canary, a comedy-thriller whose haunted-house look Universal would reuse. For The Man Who Laughs he worked with the studio's art director Charles D. Hall. Hall and Pierce are said to have carried that look into Universal's horror films of the 1930s.

The studio is reported to have spent more than a million dollars and built more than fifty sets. The part was first meant for Lon Chaney, by some accounts, who made The Phantom of the Opera instead. Mary Philbin, one of Universal's biggest stars of the time, plays Dea. Olga Baclanova plays the duchess Josiana, who is fascinated by Gwynplaine.

Sound, and the reception

The film was finished in 1927 and held until 1928. It opened in New York on 27 April, and reached general release on 4 November. The sound version has no audible dialogue: it carries a synchronised orchestral score with effects such as bells, knocks and trumpets, on disc and on film. The score is said to include the song "When Love Comes Stealing", by Ernö Rapée, with words by Walter Hirsch and Lew Pollack, which had first been recorded in 1924. Among sources only one names it, and it is hedged here. A festival essay treats it as something close to a talkie, with some incidental dialogue; other accounts say no dialogue is heard.

Critics were divided. The New York Times found it gruesome but interesting, and Paul Rotha was harshly critical. The San Francisco festival essay says critics called the story morbid and audiences largely stayed away. Later critics have judged it far more kindly, and Roger Ebert gave it four stars.

The Joker

The Joker, the Batman villain, first appeared in 1940. His creators, Bob Kane, Bill Finger and Jerry Robinson, all said the character's grin came from a photograph of Veidt as Gwynplaine. Their accounts of the rest do not match. Kane said in 1994 that Finger showed him the photograph and said it was the Joker. Finger said in 1966 that he cut the picture from a cheap edition of the book and gave it to Kane. Robinson said his own playing-card sketch came first and that Finger linked it to Veidt afterwards. All three had died by 2011, and the dispute over who saw it first stays unsettled.

Why it matters

It is a late silent showpiece. Little White Lies calls it one of the most important films of the late silent era, a big-budget picture, made just as sound arrived.

It joins German design to Hollywood. Leni and Veidt came from the world of Caligari and Waxworks, and the film is read as a step towards Universal's horror cycle.

It rests on one performance. Veidt acts through a mouth that cannot move, and critics still point to him first.

It left a face behind. Gwynplaine's grin is the image people carry away, and the Joker is the best known descendant. Leni did not live to see it: he died in Los Angeles in September 1929, aged 44, of sepsis from an untreated tooth infection. In the United States the film has been in the public domain since 1 January 2024.

On the same programme

Some of these films are rooms you can play

These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.

Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.

Quick answers

Is The Man Who Laughs based on a book?

Yes. It adapts Victor Hugo's novel L'Homme qui rit, first published in France in 1869 and set in England in the late seventeenth century. The film changes the ending: it is happier than the novel's.

Why does Gwynplaine have a permanent grin?

As a child he was sold to the comprachicos, Hugo's invented band of child-traders, who cut his mouth into a fixed smile. In the film this is done on the orders of King James II, to punish the boy's father.

How did Conrad Veidt play a permanent smile?

He wore false teeth and other apparatus in his mouth, and by most accounts it was painful. Several writers credit the make-up artist Jack Pierce with the mouthpiece. Sources do not agree on its details.

Is The Man Who Laughs a talkie?

Not quite. It has no audible dialogue and tells its story in intertitles, but it was released with a synchronised score and sound effects. One festival essay says it also has some incidental dialogue; others do not mention any.

Did The Man Who Laughs inspire the Joker?

The Joker's creators said so. Bob Kane, Bill Finger and Jerry Robinson all connected the character's grin to a photograph of Veidt as Gwynplaine, though their accounts of who found it, and when, differ.

Who directed The Man Who Laughs?

Paul Leni, a German set designer and director who made Waxworks (1924) in Germany and moved to Hollywood in 1927. He died in Los Angeles in September 1929, aged 44.

Is The Man Who Laughs in the public domain?

In the United States, yes, since 1 January 2024, when works published in 1928 entered it. Modern restorations and newly recorded scores may carry rights of their own.

Sources and further reading

  1. The Man Who Laughs (1928 film), Wikipedia: release dates, credits, sound version, song, reception, preservation
  2. The Man Who Laughs (novel), Wikipedia: Hugo's story, the comprachicos, publication in April 1869
  3. The Man Who Laughs, Dennis Harvey, San Francisco Silent Film Festival
  4. 'The Man Who Laughs' is a cautionary tale about grinning and bearing it, Apollo magazine
  5. How The Man Who Laughs redefined early horror cinema, Little White Lies
  6. Paul Leni, Wikipedia: career, move to Universal, death
  7. Conrad Veidt, Wikipedia: Cesare in Caligari, years in Hollywood, death
  8. Joker (character), Wikipedia, citing the interviews of Kane, Finger and Robinson on the character's origin
  9. Public Domain Day 2024, Center for the Study of the Public Domain, Duke University School of Law

The audience is on its way

Now play the films

Reel Trouble is a comedy platformer where every room is a movie set, from 1896 on. The free demo has six rooms, a secret room and a premiere.

Free · Desktop: browser, Windows, Mac, Linux · Played with a keyboard