Palace Picture House · Programme note
Limite 1931
A young man with a borrowed camera made one film, three people in a boat, and then watched it nearly vanish for decades.
By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 5 minute read
In short
Limite (Limit) is a Brazilian silent film of 1931, written, directed, produced and edited by Mário Peixoto, then in his early twenties. A man and two women drift in a rowing boat and remember their lives, in a film made almost entirely of images and music. It was shown only a few times, left to rot, and rescued from a single damaged nitrate print. Brazilian critics have since voted it the best Brazilian film more than once, and it remains Peixoto's only finished work in cinema.
Watch the film
It is not played on this page: see where to watch it.
Find where to stream, rent or buy it, on JustWatch.
- Original title
- Limite ("Limit")
- Released
- First public screening on 17 May 1931 at the Capitólio cinema, Rio de Janeiro
- Made by
- Mário Peixoto, who wrote, directed, produced and edited it, paid for with family money
- Cast
- Olga Breno, Taciana Rey, Raul Schnoor, Brutus Pedreira, with Peixoto and the cameraman in small parts
- Camera
- Edgar Brasil (Edgar Brazil), a German-born cinematographer working in Brazil
- Filmed
- 1930, on the coast near Mangaratiba, about 50 miles from Rio de Janeiro
- Length
- About two hours: sources give 114 to 120 minutes; silent, black and white, only three intertitles
- Copyright
- Not settled here. A Brazilian film, first shown in Rio in 1931; Peixoto died in 1992. Brazilian law, not the US term, matters most, and sources consulted do not state its status. Modern restorations and scores have rights of their own
Three people and a boat
There is no plot in the usual sense. A man and two women sit in a small boat on a calm sea. They have no food, no oars worth the name and, it seems, no hope. One woman has escaped from prison, the other has left an unhappy marriage, and the man grieves for a woman who has died. As they drift, each remembers, and the film cuts between the boat and what they recall.
What holds it together is the camera. Hands, hair, rope, waves, a cemetery, a pair of scissors, a road: close-ups of bodies and objects dissolve into each other, and the same gestures return like a refrain. The film has only three intertitles. In one scene the characters watch a Chaplin comedy in a cinema, and the film cuts between the screen and the faces in the audience.
The idea is traditionally traced to a photograph. By most accounts it was a picture, by the Hungarian photographer André Kertész, of a woman with a man's handcuffed hands around her neck, which Peixoto saw in Paris in 1929. Sources differ on the details, and one describes the picture instead as a chained woman in the magazine Vu.
Who made it
Mário Peixoto was born in Brussels in 1908 and raised in a wealthy Brazilian family. He was in Europe as a student when he saw the films of the 1920s avant-garde. He was about twenty-two when he shot Limite, though some writers give an age of nineteen or twenty-three: sources differ. He had no film experience to speak of.
The family paid. Peixoto is said to have asked two established Brazilian directors, Humberto Mauro and Adhemar Gonzaga, to make the film, and both turned it down, so he made it himself. The cameraman was Edgar Brasil, a German-born veteran who had shot many Brazilian features. The cast included Olga Breno, Taciana Rey and Raul Schnoor, and the film's musical director Brutus Pedreira, who also acted. Shooting took place in 1930 on the coast near Mangaratiba, some fifty miles from Rio, partly on a cousin's farm.
Critics have heard in it the influence of Griffith, Soviet montage, German expressionism, French avant-garde cinema and the work of Jean Epstein. For screenings, Pedreira assembled a soundtrack of existing music: by one account it used pieces by Satie, Debussy and Stravinsky, and no original score.
A film nobody wanted
The first public screening was on 17 May 1931 at the Capitólio cinema in Rio, and Some intellectuals were enthusiastic. Audiences and distributors were not. Only about three Rio screenings are recorded, between May 1931 and January 1932, and then the film went into hiding.
It survived in a handful of private shows. In 1942 the poet Vinícius de Moraes is said to have shown it to Orson Welles during the American's visit to Brazil. Film clubs kept the legend alive, and so did Peixoto, who was not above embroidering it. In 1965 he circulated an article praising the film as the work of Sergei Eisenstein. Its source was never clear, and before his death Peixoto admitted that he had written it himself. The French critic Georges Sadoul called the film an unknown masterpiece.
Peixoto's other plans came to little. His second feature, Onde a Terra Acaba, was mostly lost in a fire. He wrote poems and a novel, and in later life lived in seclusion, on an island off Rio. He died in Rio on 3 February 1992, aged 83.
The one print
There was only one copy. By 1959 the single nitrate print had deteriorated so badly in poor storage that it could not be shown. In 1966, according to one account, the police took it with other films from a university department in the dictatorship's early years, and Saulo Pereira de Mello got it back the same year.
The rescue took years of frame-by-frame work. One account credits Pereira de Mello and the physicist Plínio Sussekind Rocha with completing the restoration in 1978 after some twenty years' effort, and another account dates the work from 1966 to 1978. One scene is still missing, and an intertitle stands in for it. A newer restoration followed, announced in 2007 at the Cannes festival: a partnership between the Cinemateca Brasileira and the World Cinema Foundation, which Martin Scorsese co-founded, with the Mário Peixoto archive and, by one account, Walter Salles taking the initiative. Sources differ on who paid. Its American premiere was at the Brooklyn Academy of Music in November 2010, and the Criterion Collection issued it on disc in 2017. The film's running time is quoted as anything from 114 to 120 minutes, since speeds differ.
Why it matters
It is Brazil's most honoured silent film. The Cinemateca Brasileira named it the best Brazilian film in 1988, the newspaper Folha de S.Paulo did so in a critics' survey in 1995, and the critics' association Abraccine placed it first in 2015.
It shows what one person with a camera could do. A man in his early twenties, with family money and a borrowed crew, made a film in the manner of the European avant-garde, on a Brazilian beach.
It shows how close a film can come to vanishing. One nitrate print, one rescuer, years of work and one scene that will not come back.
Its legal status is a question, not an answer. Works first published in 1931 are due to enter the public domain in the United States on 1 January 2027, but that may not be the point for a film made and shown in Brazil. The sources consulted do not say where the film stands in Brazil, and Peixoto died in 1992. A modern restoration or score is a separate matter.
On the same programme
Some of these films are rooms you can play
These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.
-
1896
Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat
Our room: Arrival of the Pain
-
1902
A Trip to the Moon
Our room: A Trip to the Moan
-
1923
Safety Last!
Our room: Safety Second
Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.
Quick answers
What is Limite about?
A man and two women are adrift in a small boat on the open sea. Through flashbacks we see what each has left behind: a prison, an unhappy marriage, a lost love. There is hardly any plot beyond that.
Who directed Limite?
Mário Peixoto, born in Brussels in 1908 to a Brazilian family. He wrote, produced and edited it, and never finished another film.
When did Limite come out?
It was first shown in Rio de Janeiro on 17 May 1931. It had a handful of screenings over the following months and then disappeared from view.
Is Limite a lost film?
Not now, but it nearly was. Only one nitrate print survived, badly deteriorated by 1959. One scene is still missing and is replaced by an intertitle.
Who restored Limite?
Saulo Pereira de Mello led the long early restoration, completed in 1978 by most accounts. A newer restoration, announced in 2007, was made with the Cinemateca Brasileira and the World Cinema Foundation, and shown in New York in 2010.
Is Limite the best Brazilian film?
Many Brazilian critics say so. The Cinemateca Brasileira named it the best Brazilian film in 1988, a newspaper survey did the same in 1995, and a critics' association put it first in 2015.
Is Limite in the public domain?
The sources consulted do not say. Because it is a Brazilian film, Brazilian law matters most, and Peixoto died only in 1992. Check before reusing it, and note that modern restorations and scores are separate.
Where can I watch Limite?
It has been released on DVD and Blu-ray by the Criterion Collection, in the World Cinema Project series. No free, legal online copy is listed here.
Sources and further reading
- Limite, Wikipedia: the premiere, production, cast, the print's history, the restoration and the critics' polls, as reported
- Mário Peixoto, Wikipedia: his life, writings and the film's reputation
- Limite, Encyclopedia.com: plot, credits, music and the 1978 restoration
- Limite restaurado (news report), AdoroCinema, on the 2007 announcement and the World Cinema Foundation and Cinemateca Brasileira partnership
