Play the free demo Get the demo's link

Palace Picture House · Programme note

Mädchen in Uniform 1931

An all-female cast, a woman director and a schoolgirl's love for her teacher: a low-budget German film of 1931 that audiences loved and censors and exile later scattered.

By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 5 minute read

In short

Mädchen in Uniform (Girls in Uniform) is a German sound film of 1931, directed by Leontine Sagan under the supervision of Carl Froelich, from Christa Winsloe's play Gestern und heute. Set in a strict Prussian boarding school, it follows a motherless girl, Manuela, who falls in love with a kind teacher. The cast is entirely female, and the film is among the first to treat such a love with sympathy, though careful sources note that it never uses the word. It was cheap, popular across Europe, cut by the censor, and after 1933 its makers scattered into exile.

Watch the film

It is not played on this page: see where to watch it.

Mädchen in Uniform

1931

Where to watch it (opens in a new tab) on JustWatch

Find where to stream, rent or buy it, on JustWatch.

Original title
Mädchen in Uniform; English title Girls in Uniform. The play it comes from is Gestern und heute ("Yesterday and Today")
Released
Premiere in Berlin on 27 November 1931
Made by
Deutsche Film-Gemeinschaft, a company formed for the film. Director Leontine Sagan; artistic direction and production Carl Froelich; screenplay Christa Winsloe and Friedrich Dammann (credited as F. D. Andam)
Cast
Hertha Thiele (Manuela), Dorothea Wieck (Fräulein von Bernburg), Emilia Unda (the headmistress), Ellen Schwanneke (Ilse), Erika Mann (Fräulein von Atems)
Filmed
Largely at the Great Military Orphanage in Potsdam, with studio work in Berlin-Tempelhof
Length
About 88 minutes. The censor passed 2,682 metres for adults only on 1 October 1931 and a shortened 2,480 metres in April 1932
Format
Sound, black and white, German
Copyright
Due to enter the public domain in the United States on 1 January 2027, with the other works of 1931, as the usual references list them. Germany protects a film for 70 years after the death of the last of its principal creators, and Sagan died in 1974: check before reusing. A restored print or subtitles are separate

The story

Manuela von Meinhardis is a motherless teenager. She is sent to a boarding school in Prussia, run on strict discipline. The headmistress, played by Emilia Unda, tells the girls they are children of soldiers, and by one account adds that she hopes they will be the mothers of soldiers too.

The one warm presence is a teacher, Fräulein von Bernburg, who kisses each girl goodnight. Manuela, whose goodnight kiss from her falls on the lips, falls in love with her. After a school play, and a drink at a party, Manuela announces her love in front of everyone. The headmistress forbids all contact. Manuela climbs the school's great staircase to throw herself down it, and the other girls, who have come to see what the school does, run to stop her. The headmistress is left standing in the silence she made.

A play, a cooperative and an all-female cast

The story is Christa Winsloe's. She was sent as a girl to a strict boarding school in Potsdam after her mother died, and she wrote the play first staged in Leipzig as Ritter Nérestan and then in Berlin in 1931 as Gestern und heute. Sources agree that in the play Manuela dies. The film changed that.

Carl Froelich, an established producer, funded the picture and set up a company for it, the Deutsche Film-Gemeinschaft. By one account it was the first German film made as a cooperative, with cast and crew paid partly in shares. The budget is given as only 55,000 Reichsmarks. He offered the direction to Leontine Sagan, a Budapest-born stage director who had trained with Max Reinhardt, and he kept the artistic direction, so that some sources credit him as director. Winsloe was on the set, and she insisted on Hertha Thiele for Manuela. Dorothea Wieck played the teacher. Much of the film was shot at the Great Military Orphanage in Potsdam, where the staircase stands.

Sagan worked in close-ups, dissolves and suggestive music, leaving the unspoken to carry the story. Critics have compared the faces to those in Dreyer's The Passion of Joan of Arc. The cast is all female.

The censors and the success

The film opened in Berlin on 27 November 1931. A film committee had already passed 2,682 metres for adults only on 1 October, and in April 1932 a shortened version of 2,480 metres was approved. In Germany it was overshadowed by The Blue Angel, but it did well across Europe, above all in Romania. One account says it brought in about six million Reichsmarks by 1934, though the cast and crew are said to have been paid only a quarter of normal wages, and Thiele suggested that the producers kept most of the money.

It was almost banned in the United States. By one account Eleanor Roosevelt, then the wife of New York's governor, praised it, and a limited release followed in 1932 and 1933. Not every critic was convinced: Siegfried Kracauer argued that it fails to challenge authoritarian habits. Later critics, among them B. Ruby Rich, praised it as one of the first screen portraits of queer love.

After 1933

Here the sources part. Many accounts say Joseph Goebbels banned the film, as "decadent" or as an attack on Prussian discipline and authority rather than on its love story, and some add that an alternative ending let it play for a while. A German reference work says the film was not banned in the Nazi period at all, and that its Jewish contributors lost their credits. Both agree that its makers did not stay.

Sagan left Germany for Britain in 1933, and in 1939 went with her husband to South Africa, where she died in Pretoria in 1974. Thiele, who refused to work on propaganda, was shut out of the Reich's theatre and film chambers and moved to Switzerland in 1937. She worked for years as a psychiatric nursing assistant, and died in East Berlin in 1984. Winsloe fled in the 1930s, and on 10 June 1944 she and her partner Simone Gentet were shot dead near Cluny, in France, by four men who accused them of spying for the Germans. The film was approved for adults again in West Germany in 1949, and was shown publicly there only in 1977. A remake of 1958 with Lilli Palmer and Romy Schneider softened the love story.

Why it matters

It put a schoolgirl's love on the screen without a joke or a punishment aimed at her. The kiss is the film's best-known scene, and the British Film Institute reads the ending as a plea for tolerance.

It was made by women, about women. A woman directed, a woman wrote the play and the cast is all female, in 1931.

It shows how a school makes obedience. The school is a state in miniature, which is why the film was read as political.

It survived being scattered. It was rediscovered by women's film festivals in the 1970s, and its makers' stories are a map of the exile of 1933.

On the same programme

Some of these films are rooms you can play

These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.

Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.

Quick answers

What is Mädchen in Uniform about?

Manuela, a motherless girl, is sent to a strict boarding school in Prussia and falls in love with a kind teacher, Fräulein von Bernburg. When her feelings become public she is punished, and she tries to end her life, but her classmates save her.

Is Mädchen in Uniform a lesbian film?

It is widely regarded as one of the first films to show love between a girl and a woman with sympathy. Careful critics add that the film never names it and leaves the teacher's feelings open.

Who directed Mädchen in Uniform?

Leontine Sagan, a Budapest-born theatre director who had trained under Max Reinhardt. Carl Froelich, who funded the film, kept artistic direction, and some sources credit him as director.

Was Mädchen in Uniform banned by the Nazis?

Sources differ. Many accounts say Joseph Goebbels banned it, as "decadent" or for its attack on Prussian discipline. A German reference work says it was not banned in the Nazi period. Jewish contributors, Sagan among them, lost their credits.

What happened to the people who made Mädchen in Uniform?

Sagan left Germany in 1933 for Britain and later South Africa. Hertha Thiele refused propaganda work and went to Switzerland in 1937. Christa Winsloe was shot dead in France in June 1944.

Does the film end in suicide?

In the film, Manuela tries to throw herself down the staircase and her classmates stop her. In Winsloe's play, by one account, the story ends in her suicide.

Is Mädchen in Uniform in the public domain?

In the United States it is due to join the other works of 1931 on 1 January 2027. In Germany a film is protected for 70 years after the death of its last principal creator, and Sagan died in 1974, so it is probably protected there for many years yet.

Sources and further reading

  1. Mädchen in Uniform (1931 film), Wikipedia: production, cast, censorship and reception, as reported
  2. Mädchen in Uniform (1931), German Wikipedia: censorship dates, locations and the Nazi-era question
  3. How a school drama with an all-female cast broke down doors for queer cinema, 90 years ago, British Film Institute
  4. Mädchen in Uniform, Encyclopedia.com, film reference entry
  5. Leontine Sagan, Wikipedia: her life and exile
  6. Christa Winsloe, Wikipedia: the playwright's life and death
  7. Hertha Thiele, Wikipedia: the star's life after the film

The audience is on its way

Now play the films

Reel Trouble is a comedy platformer where every room is a movie set, from 1896 on. The free demo has six rooms, a secret room and a premiere.

Free · Desktop: browser, Windows, Mac, Linux · Played with a keyboard