Palace Picture House · Programme note
Susan Lenox (Her Fall and Rise) 1931
Greta Garbo and Clark Gable made one film together, from a novel so notorious that British censors banned the picture before anyone had seen it.
By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 5 minute read
In short
Susan Lenox (Her Fall and Rise) is an American drama of 1931, directed by Robert Z. Leonard for MGM, and the only film in which Greta Garbo and Clark Gable appear together. It adapts David Graham Phillips's novel of 1917 about a girl who runs from a brutal home and works her way up through a circus, a rich man's flat and a South American dance hall. British censors banned it on the novel's reputation, then passed it, cut and retitled. It is a pre-Code film, a box-office success and a famously awkward pairing.
Watch the film
It is not played on this page: see where to watch it.
Find where to stream, rent or buy it, on JustWatch.
- Original title
- Susan Lenox (Her Fall and Rise); in Britain, after the ban, The Rise of Helga
- Released
- 10 September 1931 in the United States
- Made by
- Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. Director and producer Robert Z. Leonard; camera William H. Daniels; editor Margaret Booth; music William Axt and Leo F. Forbstein
- Written by
- Screenplay credited to Leon Gordon, Zelda Sears, Edith Fitzgerald and Wanda Tuchock; story credit to Paul Bern and others
- Cast
- Greta Garbo (Susan Lenox), Clark Gable (Rodney Spencer), Jean Hersholt (Karl Ohlin), John Miljan (Wayne Burlingham), Alan Hale (Jeb Mondstrum), Hale Hamilton (Mike Kelly), Ian Keith (Robert Lane)
- Source
- The novel Susan Lenox: Her Fall and Rise by David Graham Phillips, published in 1917
- Length and format
- About 76 minutes; sound, black and white, English
- Copyright
- Published in 1931, so due to enter the public domain in the United States on 1 January 2027, with the other works of 1931, unless a record shows a different date. The 1917 novel is a separate work. A modern restoration or score has rights of its own
The story
Helga Ohlin is an illegitimate child raised in a hard house. Her uncle Karl Ohlin has arranged her marriage to Jeb Mondstrum, a brute. She runs away and meets Rodney Spencer, an architect renting a cabin nearby. When he leaves, Jeb and her father find her again, and she escapes on a train and joins a circus troupe as a dancer. She takes the name Susan Lenox.
On the train the police search for her, and the troupe's leader Wayne Burlingham hides her in his quarters and takes advantage of her. She writes to Rodney, asking him to meet her in Marquette. When they meet, the two misunderstand each other over her past, and he leaves. She goes to New York and becomes the mistress of a politician, Mike Kelly. At a dinner in his penthouse she invites Rodney under false pretences, and a second misunderstanding sends him away again.
Susan learns that Rodney has left home for an unknown destination and vows to find him. She ends up a dancer in a South American dance hall, where an American, Robert Lane, courts her. She still longs for Rodney and vows to rise or fall alone. At the end a barge of swamp workers reaches the port, Rodney is among them, and after some arguing the two come together. It is a happy ending for a heroine who has done a good deal of falling.
The novel and the title
The source is a novel by David Graham Phillips, an American journalist and writer. He was shot near the Princeton Club in Gramercy Park, New York, on 23 January 1911 and died the next day in Bellevue Hospital. Susan Lenox: Her Fall and Rise came out in 1917, six years after his death, with his sister Carolyn putting the final manuscript in order. It caused a stir because its heroine is driven by circumstance to sell herself in order to live.
The long title, Her Fall and Rise, is the novel's own subtitle, and it also describes the shape of the story. Sources do not say why MGM kept it in brackets after the heroine's name. In Britain the title was changed, for reasons told below.
Garbo and Gable
By 1931 Greta Garbo was, by one account, the most popular female star in the United States, and she had held that place in 1930 as well. Clark Gable was relatively unknown. MGM had put him in a run of supporting parts, and this film is often described as a way of lifting him with her fame. The studio's advertising leaned on it, selling the film as Garbo in Gable's arms.
Retellings agree that Garbo had wanted to work with Gable and helped bring the pairing about. Gable, it is said, learnt of his casting from a Hollywood trade paper, and was put out, though he came round to seeing the part as a smart step and a chance to learn from a star. Several accounts add that the two did not like each other, and that the pairing looks awkward on screen. Treat the details with care: they come from later retellings rather than from records of the set.
The script had many hands. The final credits name four screenwriters, with the story credited to Paul Bern and others, and one account says as many as two dozen writers worked on it. The director was Robert Z. Leonard, who also produced, with William H. Daniels behind the camera. The film runs about 76 minutes.
Censors and reception
Britain moved first. British censors banned the film on the notoriety of the novel alone. It was passed later, after a few cuts, under the new title The Rise of Helga. Which scenes were cut is not clear from the sources read here, and nothing is said of cuts made for American audiences.
At home the film belongs to the pre-Code years. The Production Code was announced in 1930, but the body that enforced it, the Production Code Administration, only began to demand scripts and certificates in 1934. One listing of 1931 films counts this one as evidence of the freer years, noting that the heroine faces constant threats of rape and abuse before she turns to prostitution and gold digging.
Mordaunt Hall of The New York Times, writing on 17 October 1931, praised Garbo's performance and the camera work. He found the dialogue choppy and the incidents hurried, and found little drama in the telling. Audiences were kinder. On a budget of about $580,000, MGM's records, as quoted, show $806,000 earned in the United States and Canada and $700,000 elsewhere, a profit of $364,000.
Why it matters
It is the only time they shared a screen. Garbo and Gable never made another film together. Talk of a reunion in Red Dust (1932) came to nothing, and Gable made that picture with Jean Harlow instead.
It shows what a notorious book could do to a film. A reputation earned in print in 1917 was enough to have the picture banned in Britain fourteen years later, and the cure was a few cuts and a new name.
It is a clear case of pre-Code frankness. A woman is wronged, falls and rises, and the ending is a happy one. The Code was enforced strictly from 1934.
It is part of the class of 1931. Works first published in 1931 are due to enter the United States public domain on 1 January 2027. The film's own copyright record decides the matter for this title, and the 1917 novel is a separate work.
On the same programme
Some of these films are rooms you can play
These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.
-
1896
Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat
Our room: Arrival of the Pain
-
1902
A Trip to the Moon
Our room: A Trip to the Moan
-
1923
Safety Last!
Our room: Safety Second
Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.
Quick answers
Is Susan Lenox the only film Garbo and Gable made together?
Yes. Susan Lenox (Her Fall and Rise) was their only screen pairing. Talk of reuniting them in Red Dust (1932) came to nothing, and Gable made that film with Jean Harlow.
What is Susan Lenox about?
A girl called Helga Ohlin flees a forced marriage to a brutal man, joins a circus, becomes a rich man's mistress in New York and ends up a dancer in South America. All the while she loves an architect, Rodney Spencer, with whom she keeps missing.
Is Susan Lenox based on a book?
Yes, on David Graham Phillips's novel Susan Lenox: Her Fall and Rise, published in 1917, six years after the author's death. It was controversial because its heroine is driven to sell herself to survive.
Why was Susan Lenox banned in Britain?
British censors banned it on the notoriety of the novel alone. It was passed later, after a few cuts, under the new title The Rise of Helga.
Did Garbo and Gable get on?
By most accounts, no. Several retellings say they did not like each other, and the pairing is often called awkward on screen. Gable is also said to have learnt of his casting from a trade paper.
Is Susan Lenox a pre-Code film?
Yes. The Production Code was announced in 1930 but not strictly enforced until the Production Code Administration began requiring certificates in 1934, so a film of 1931 falls in the freer years.
Did Susan Lenox make money?
Yes. On a budget of about $580,000, MGM's own records, as quoted, show $806,000 earned in the United States and Canada and $700,000 elsewhere, a profit of $364,000.
Is Susan Lenox in the public domain?
Works first published in 1931 are due to enter the United States public domain on 1 January 2027. Check the film's own copyright record, since registration and renewal can change the date. A restored print or new score has rights of its own.
Sources and further reading
- Susan Lenox (Her Fall and Rise), Wikipedia: credits, plot, budget, takings, Mordaunt Hall's review and the British ban
- Susan Lenox (Her Fall and Rise), Turner Classic Movies, article: casting, writers and the British retitling
- David Graham Phillips, Wikipedia: the author's death in 1911 and the novel's posthumous publication
- Pre-Code: Hollywood before the censors, British Film Institute, Sight and Sound: the Code of 1930 and its enforcement from 1934
- Pre-Code listings for 1931, pre-code.com, on the film's frank treatment of its heroine
- Greta Garbo, Wikipedia: Garbo's standing at MGM in 1931 and the films of that year
- Lifecycle of Copyright: 1930 Works in the Public Domain, Library of Congress, Copyright Office blog, 2025: works of 1930 entering on 1 January 2026
