Palace Picture House · Programme note
The Bad Sister 1931
A small-town flirt, a con man and a quiet sister: Universal's pre-Code drama is remembered as the film where Bette Davis began.
By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 5 minute read
In short
The Bad Sister is an American drama of 1931, directed by Hobart Henley for Universal and based on Booth Tarkington's novel The Flirt (1913). Sidney Fox is the bored small-town girl of the title, Conrad Nagel the doctor, and Humphrey Bogart the con man who ruins her. In the supporting role of the plain, patient sister is Bette Davis, in her first film. It was no success, and Universal let her go within a year, but the picture is now watched for her, and for the pre-Code frankness of its story.
Watch the film
There is no clean free copy to play or link to here.
The Bad Sister
1931
- Original title
- Bad Sister on most listings; the opening credits read The Bad Sister. Made as What a Flirt; briefly retitled Gambling Daughters before its general release
- Released
- Late March 1931 in the United States: 29 March by one listing, 23 March by another
- Made by
- Universal Pictures. Director Hobart Henley; producer Carl Laemmle Jr.; screenplay Edwin H. Knopf, Tom Reed and Raymond L. Schrock; camera Karl Freund; editor Ted J. Kent; music David Broekman
- Cast
- Sidney Fox (Marianne), Conrad Nagel (Dr. Dick Lindley), Bette Davis (Laura), Humphrey Bogart (Valentine Corliss), Charles Winninger, Emma Dunn, ZaSu Pitts, Slim Summerville
- Source
- The Flirt (1913), a novel by Booth Tarkington, filmed before in 1916 and 1922
- Length
- About 68 minutes
- Format
- Sound, black and white; English; a pre-Code drama
- Copyright
- Works first published in the United States in 1931 are due to enter the public domain there on 1 January 2027, if their copyright was renewed; sources differ on whether this film's was, so check before relying on it. A print is held by the Library of Congress
The story
Marianne Madison is bored. Her small town offers little to a pretty girl with many suitors, and she sleeps late, flirts, and waits for something to happen. It arrives in the shape of Valentine Corliss, a smooth-talking swindler who appears about twenty minutes into the film. They spend a night together, and he leaves her behind.
Her sister Laura is the other kind of girl: kind, reserved, and in love with Dr. Dick Lindley, who does not return her feelings. Marianne's family is in debt. In the end she marries Wade Trumbull, a wealthy man who pays her father's creditors, and finds she has grown fond of him. It is a short, moral tale of just over an hour, in which the flirt is punished and rewarded in about equal parts.
The title does the work of a poster. In the story the bad sister is Marianne, and the good one is the sister nobody looks at.
From a Tarkington novel
The film comes from The Flirt, a novel of 1913 by Booth Tarkington. Tarkington won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction twice, in 1919 for The Magnificent Ambersons and in 1922 for Alice Adams. In the 1910s and 1920s he was thought by many to be the greatest living American novelist. His reputation has since fallen a long way, and his stories are filmed far less often than they once were.
Universal knew the book well. It filmed The Flirt as a silent picture in 1922, also directed by Hobart Henley, and that version is now considered lost. Henley was a former stage and silent-film actor, born in Louisville in 1887, who had turned to directing by 1919. For the sound version the screenplay was credited to Edwin H. Knopf, Tom Reed and Raymond L. Schrock, and the producer was Carl Laemmle Jr., the son of Universal's founder.
The title wandered. The picture was made as What a Flirt, the credits read The Bad Sister, most listings drop the article, and shortly before its general release it was briefly sold as Gambling Daughters. The release date is also given two ways, 23 and 29 March 1931, so late March is the safe answer.
The cast
Sidney Fox, billed first, plays Marianne. She was a Broadway actress whom Laemmle Jr. is said to have seen on stage in 1930 and signed to Universal. This was her Hollywood debut. She went on to Strictly Dishonorable and, opposite Bela Lugosi, Murders in the Rue Morgue (1932). She died in 1942 of an overdose of sleeping pills, which an inquiry ruled accidental.
Conrad Nagel, a leading man of the silent era, plays the doctor. The father is Charles Winninger and the mother Emma Dunn, with ZaSu Pitts as the servant Minnie and Slim Summerville in a comic part. The camera was in the hands of Karl Freund, who had photographed The Last Laugh and Metropolis in Germany, reached Hollywood in 1929, and shot Dracula the same year as this film.
Two future stars
Humphrey Bogart plays Valentine Corliss. It is often said to be where he began, but it was not: he had made a short in 1928, and by 1930 he had a feature, A Devil with Women, and John Ford's Up the River behind him. Here he was a fresh-faced stage actor lent to Universal, with a thin voice and little of the screen presence he later had. Davis remembered him as being dismissed by the studio after the film, but a modern account notes that he was under contract elsewhere and simply went back to Broadway.
Bette Davis, 22, had come to Hollywood in 1930 to test for Universal and by one account failed her first test. Carl Laemmle is said to have considered sending her home. Freund told him she had lovely eyes, and she was given Laura. Biographers say that studio men thought her plain, and that the part of the dutiful, shadowed sister played against the glamour they expected of a star.
She hated it. By her own later accounts she found her makeup test dispiriting, thought she was bad on the screen, and left the preview believing her career was over. In her memoir she judged the film deadly and blamed it for her losing her place at Universal. After a year and six films, none of them successful, Laemmle did not renew her contract. George Arliss then picked her for The Man Who Played God (1932) at Warner Bros., which signed her for seven years and kept her for eighteen.
Why it matters
It is where Bette Davis starts. A first film that its star remembered as a disaster is a gift to historians: the picture is seen now chiefly because of what came after it.
It shows pre-Code Hollywood at its plainest. The story of a girl who spends a night with a swindler, with no pretence that nothing happened, was told in 1931 before the Production Code was enforced in 1934.
It is a small lesson in how careers go. The studio dropped Davis and promoted Sidney Fox, and the future went the other way.
It survives. A print is reported to be in the Library of Congress collection. Its copyright is for 2027 to settle: a 1931 American film is due to enter the public domain on 1 January 2027 if its copyright was renewed.
On the same programme
Some of these films are rooms you can play
These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.
-
1896
Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat
Our room: Arrival of the Pain
-
1902
A Trip to the Moon
Our room: A Trip to the Moan
-
1923
Safety Last!
Our room: Safety Second
Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.
Quick answers
Was Bad Sister Bette Davis's first film?
Yes. Her biographies and the usual film references give Bad Sister (1931) as her screen debut. She plays Laura, the quiet sister, and is billed below Sidney Fox.
Was Humphrey Bogart in Bad Sister?
Yes, as the smooth con man Valentine Corliss. It was not his first film: he had appeared in a short in 1928 and in features in 1930, and was on loan to Universal for this one.
What is Bad Sister about?
Marianne, bored with her small town, falls for a travelling swindler who leaves her. Her plain sister Laura loves the local doctor, who does not notice her. Marianne later marries a rich suitor who pays her father's debts.
Is Bad Sister based on a book?
Yes: The Flirt (1913) by Booth Tarkington, the American novelist who won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction in 1919 and 1922. Universal had filmed it in 1922 as a silent film, also directed by Hobart Henley.
Why did Bette Davis dislike Bad Sister?
By her own later accounts she thought she was poor in it, and she took its failure to mean her career was over. Universal did not renew her contract after her first year and six films.
Why was it called Gambling Daughters?
It carried that title briefly before its general release in 1931. The film was made as What a Flirt, and the credits read The Bad Sister.
Is Bad Sister in the public domain?
Films first published in the United States in 1931 are due to enter the public domain there on 1 January 2027 if their copyright was renewed, and earlier if it was not. Sources do not settle which applies to this one. Modern transfers can have rights of their own.
Sources and further reading
- Bad Sister (1931 film), Wikipedia: credits, cast, titles, release, running time, the Davis anecdotes
- Bette Davis's First Film With Humphrey Bogart Was A Low Point For Both, SlashFilm, drawing on Davis's memoir and her biographers
- Bette Davis, Wikipedia: her arrival at Universal, Karl Freund, her contract
- Humphrey Bogart, Wikipedia: his early screen work
- Sidney Fox, Wikipedia: her screen debut, her Universal contract and her death
- Booth Tarkington, Wikipedia: his Pulitzer Prizes and his reputation
- The Flirt (1922 film), Wikipedia: the earlier Universal version
- Karl Freund, Wikipedia: the cinematographer's career
- Hobart Henley, Wikipedia: the director's career
