Play the free demo Get the demo's link

Palace Picture House · Programme note

The Last Command 1928

A Russian general ends up as a Hollywood extra, and the revolutionary he once jailed casts him as a general for the cameras.

By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 6 minute read

In short

The Last Command is an American silent film of 1928, directed by Josef von Sternberg for Paramount, with Emil Jannings as a Russian general who has become a Hollywood extra. A director who was once his prisoner casts him as a general in a war picture. The idea is said to come from a real émigré officer seen working as an extra. Jannings won the first Academy Award for Best Actor for this film and The Way of All Flesh. The Library of Congress added The Last Command to the National Film Registry in 2006, and it entered the US public domain on 1 January 2024.

Watch the film

The whole film: 88 minutes, silent, with no music.

Played from Wikimedia Commons, which hosts this copy as a public-domain work. Nothing is fetched from there until you press play. If it will not play here, it will on their page.

Released
January 1928 in the United States (22 January by one account); it is said to have set a house record at New York's Rialto Theatre that month
Director
Josef von Sternberg
Studio
Paramount Famous Lasky Corporation, producers Adolph Zukor and Jesse L. Lasky
Cast
Emil Jannings (Grand Duke Sergius Alexander), Evelyn Brent (Natalie Dabrova), William Powell (Leo Andreyev)
Writers
Story by Lajos Bíró, screenplay by John F. Goodrich, titles by Herman J. Mankiewicz
Crew
Camera Bert Glennon, editing William Shea, art direction Hans Dreier
Format
Silent, black and white, English intertitles; about 88 minutes by the Library of Congress and TCM, 85 by another account
Copyright
Public domain in the United States since 1 January 2024, when works of 1928 entered it. Any newer score, restoration or added material can have rights of its own

The story

The film opens in Hollywood. Leo Andreyev, a director, is casting a war picture. Among the extras is a shabby old man called Sergius Alexander, who is handed a uniform in a long, dehumanising queue. A flashback shows who he was: a Russian grand duke and commander during the Revolution, proud, cruel and certain of his own importance.

Leo, then a young revolutionary, was his prisoner, and Sergius treated him badly. Natalie Dabrova, a revolutionary herself, has fallen for the general. When the Bolsheviks stop their train, she frees him and pays for it with her life. Sergius is left with a nervous twitch of the head.

Back in Hollywood, Leo recognises him and casts him as a general in the battle scene, in part as a revenge. On the set Sergius slips into the past, gives orders to men who are only actors and dies on his feet, asking whether the battle has been won. Leo tells him that it has.

Where the idea came from

The best-known account gives the idea to Ernst Lubitsch, who is said to have told a newspaper columnist, Gilbert Swan, about a real émigré: a former Imperial Russian general whom he had known in Russia and later in New York, and who turned up at a studio in uniform looking for extra work at $7.50 a day. The man is usually named as Theodore Lodijensky, who later took small parts under the name Theodore Lodi. Lubitsch is said to have passed the tale to the film's writer, Lajos Bíró, or to Jannings.

Sources differ on the details. One version puts the encounter on the set of Lubitsch's The Student Prince in Old Heidelberg and the man as the owner of a Hollywood Russian restaurant. Credit was disputed too. Paramount credited Bíró with the story and John F. Goodrich with the script. Sternberg said he wrote the manuscript himself, and Jannings claimed the idea in his memoirs; the Academy's library is said to hold an eleven-page synopsis titled The General that supports him. When a claimant later sued the studio over story credit, everyone is said to have pointed at Lubitsch, and Paramount settled.

Emil Jannings and the first Oscar

Emil Jannings was the biggest German star of his day. Paramount, which had ties with the German company Ufa, brought him to Hollywood, and The Way of All Flesh (1927) came first. Sergius is a gift of a part: pride, collapse and a death scene. Critics have long split on him. Some admire the grandeur and others find the emotion laid on too thick.

At the first Academy Awards he won Best Actor for both films. The rules of that first year let a performer be honoured for several roles, and it was the only year that happened. The nominees had been announced in February 1929. The ceremony was a private dinner at the Hollywood Roosevelt Hotel on 16 May 1929, a quarter of an hour long. By one account Jannings was told of his win in advance, posed with the statuette and left for Germany. Lajos Bíró was nominated for Best Original Story for this film; Ben Hecht won it for Underworld.

A popular tale says the dog Rin Tin Tin won the most votes and the Academy gave the prize to the runner-up. Its source is a claim by a biographer of the dog. Most sources call it untrue, and one account says only that the dog was disqualified for not being human. Treat it as a story, not a fact. The talkies ended Jannings's American career, partly because of his heavy accent. In Germany, after 1933, he made films for the Nazi state, which finished him after the war.

Sternberg's style

Josef von Sternberg had just made Underworld (1927), which established his name and, according to one critic, doubled his pay. Paramount gave him a free hand. The shoot took about five weeks, with Bert Glennon on camera and Hans Dreier designing the sets.

The look is Sternberg's: pools of light, shadows that stand for a mood and props that carry meaning, such as furs and cigarettes. His Hollywood, in particular, runs like a factory. An early tracking shot follows Jannings through the service windows of a studio wardrobe, an assembly line an intertitle calls the "bread line of Hollywood". The film links that inspection of extras to the inspection of soldiers later on.

Evelyn Brent, who had been in Underworld, plays Natalie, and William Powell plays Leo, the director who recognises the general. Both support a film built around Jannings.

Release and reputation

Paramount's executives disliked the film's view of Hollywood and its portrait of the Revolution, and the release was held back. A Paramount stockholder, Otto Kahn by one account, is said to have pressed the studio to let it out. It opened in January 1928 and by one account broke the record at New York's Rialto. It won critical praise but brought the studio little profit.

The Library of Congress selected it for the National Film Registry in 2006. The 1928 copyright was renewed, so the film did not enter the public domain in the United States until 1 January 2024, when Duke's Center for the Study of the Public Domain listed it among the films of 1928 that became free to use. Duke adds that newly added material, such as a musical score, may still be protected.

Why it matters

It is a film about Hollywood made inside Hollywood. It shows the extras' queue, the set and the cruelty of casting. Critics have suggested it fed into Sunset Blvd. twenty-two years later.

It put the first Best Actor Oscar on a silent performance. Jannings's win, shared with The Way of All Flesh, is the reason many people have heard of the film.

It is Sternberg at full strength. Light, crowds and a doomed man in a uniform make a case for the director before the Marlene Dietrich films.

It is free to use. Since 2024 the film itself is out of copyright in the United States.

On the same programme

Some of these films are rooms you can play

These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.

Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.

Quick answers

What is The Last Command (1928) about?

A former Russian grand duke, now a down-at-heel Hollywood extra, is cast as a general by a director who knew him in the Revolution. In flashback we see how he lost everything, and in the end he relives a battle on the set.

Is The Last Command based on a true story?

Only loosely. By one widely repeated account, Ernst Lubitsch told the story of a real émigré Russian general working as a film extra, and it became the film's starting point. Accounts differ on the details, and the story credit was disputed.

Did Emil Jannings win an Oscar for The Last Command?

Yes, in part. He won the first Academy Award for Best Actor for his work in this film and in The Way of All Flesh (1927). The rules of that first year allowed one award for more than one film.

Who directed The Last Command?

Josef von Sternberg, a year after Underworld (1927). Paramount gave him a freer hand after that film's success.

Is The Last Command in the National Film Registry?

Yes. The Library of Congress selected it for preservation in the National Film Registry in 2006.

Is The Last Command in the public domain?

In the United States, yes, since 1 January 2024, when films of 1928 entered the public domain. Newly added material, such as a recorded score, can still be protected.

Who was the real general behind The Last Command?

He is usually named as Theodore Lodijensky, a former officer of the Imperial Russian army who is said to have sought work as an extra. The tale is secondhand and sources disagree on where and when Lubitsch saw him.

How long is The Last Command?

About 88 minutes, according to the Library of Congress and Turner Classic Movies. Another account gives 85 minutes. Silent films vary with projection speed.

Sources and further reading

  1. The Last Command (1928 film), Wikipedia: the plot, the credits, the Lubitsch anecdote, the production, the Registry and the copyright
  2. The Last Command (1928), San Francisco Silent Film Festival, programme essay
  3. The Last Command: Josef von Sternberg's Life and Death of a Russian Extra, Senses of Cinema, Great Directors critics' picks
  4. The Last Command (1928), Turner Classic Movies, TCM article
  5. Public Domain Day 2024, Duke University School of Law, Center for the Study of the Public Domain
  6. Emil Jannings, Wikipedia: his Hollywood years, the Oscar and his later career
  7. 1st Academy Awards, Wikipedia: the nominees, the ceremony and the announcement of the winners

The audience is on its way

Now play the films

Reel Trouble is a comedy platformer where every room is a movie set, from 1896 on. The free demo has six rooms, a secret room and a premiere.

Free · Desktop: browser, Windows, Mac, Linux · Played with a keyboard