Play the free demo Get the demo's link

Palace Picture House · Programme note

Gertie the Dinosaur 1914

A cartoonist stood on a vaudeville stage, ordered a dinosaur about on the screen behind him, and gave animation its first star with a personality.

By HertzyPertzy · Updated · 5 minute read

In short

Gertie the Dinosaur is an American animated short of 1914 by the newspaper cartoonist Winsor McCay. It began as a vaudeville act in which McCay, standing beside the screen, appeared to give orders to a trained dinosaur, and it was later released to cinemas with a live-action prologue. It was not the first animated film, but it is the earliest to feature a dinosaur, and it is often praised as the first cartoon whose character has an appealing personality. It is in the National Film Registry and is in the public domain in the United States.

Watch the film

The whole film: about 18 minutes, with its live-action prologue and its intertitles, silent, with no music. From the 2004 DVD Winsor McCay: The Master Edition.

Played from Wikimedia Commons, which hosts this copy as a public-domain work. Nothing is fetched from there until you press play. If it will not play here, it will on their page.

Original title
Gertie the Dinosaur; the cinema release was billed as Winsor McCay, the Famous Cartoonist, and Gertie
Made by
Winsor McCay, who drew and directed it; his neighbour, the art student John Fitzsimmons, traced the backgrounds
Stage debut
February 1914, in McCay's vaudeville act; sources differ on the first venue (Chicago's Palace Theater on 8 February by one account, a New York theatre in late February by another)
Cinema release
From 28 December 1914, through William Fox's Box Office Attractions Company, with a live-action prologue
Length
One reel: sources give about seven to twelve minutes, depending on the version and the speed
Technique
Thousands of drawings on thin Japanese paper, photographed frame by frame on 35 mm film; ink on paper, no cels
Format
Silent, black and white (35 mm)
Copyright
Public domain in the United States, and the Public Domain Review also marks it as public domain 70 years after the author's death; McCay died in 1934. Modern restorations and added scores can carry rights of their own

What is on screen

A lake, a mountain and a cave, drawn in thin lines on a white ground. A dinosaur ambles out of the cave. She is Gertie, a long-necked sauropod, and she is not shy. She drains the lake to quench her thirst, and tosses a mammoth named Jumbo into the water. When McCay scolds her for it, she cries.

In the cinema version McCay himself appears first in live action, with friends who include the cartoonists George McManus and Tad Dorgan. They bet him a dinner that he cannot bring a dinosaur to life. The wager is part of the film's story, not a record of how it was made. Then the drawings begin.

The cartoonist

Winsor McCay was a newspaper man first. His full-page Sunday strip Little Nemo in Slumberland began in the New York Herald in October 1905, and its dream worlds made him famous. His first film, Little Nemo, reached cinemas in April 1911, and by one account it took about four thousand drawings on thin paper. A year later came How a Mosquito Operates, in which a giant, carefully animated insect drains a sleeping man's blood. Both went into his vaudeville act. Gertie came next, and McCay is said to have begun the main work in mid-1913.

The act

Gertie was first a stage turn, from February 1914. Accounts differ on where: one gives Chicago's Palace Theater on 8 February, another a New York theatre later that month. McCay appeared with a whip, lectured a little on animation, and introduced her as the only dinosaur in captivity. The film ran on the screen beside him and he gave Gertie her cues. She came out of her cave, and McCay tossed a cardboard apple at the screen, turned his back, and palmed it as an apple appeared in the picture for her to eat. At the end McCay walked off the stage and appeared in the picture, where Gertie carried him away on her back.

This was not the version people see now. McCay's employer, William Randolph Hearst, restricted his stage work, and one account links that to the cinema version, which needed no man on the stage. The cinema release of 28 December 1914, through William Fox's Box Office Attractions Company, replaced the patter with the live-action prologue and intertitles.

How it was drawn

McCay drew every frame by hand on thin, translucent Japanese paper; some accounts call it rice paper, others mulberry. The framing story claims ten thousand drawings, though two modern historians think that number suspect. At sixteen frames a second, ten thousand would run for about eleven minutes, so the claim is at least the right size. The drawings were photographed at Vitagraph's studio in early 1914.

The labour was shared. The art student John Fitzsimmons, a neighbour, did the tedious retracing of the backgrounds onto each sheet, so that the hills and the lake stayed put while Gertie moved. Registration marks in the corners of the sheets kept the pictures from jittering. McCay also used what is called the split system: draw the major poses first, then the frames between them. And he drew cycles, short movements such as breathing or swaying, and reused them. Some accounts call this a first for animation; sources differ on how new each of these devices was.

The patent fight

John Randolph Bray, another animator, saw McCay's methods while the film was in production, and he took out patents on many such techniques, among them the cycling of drawings to make repeated action. He sued McCay in 1914. By the usual account the suit was unsuccessful, and McCay received royalty payments from Bray for licensing the techniques. Sources give no settlement figures.

Survival

The film was shot on 35 mm nitrate stock, which is flammable and decays. A pair of young animators found it in 1947 and saved what they could. The Cinémathèque québécoise has held McCay's films since the 1960s. McCay had cut the original film for the cinema version, and the encore scene was lost. In 2018 a Canada and United States team completed a reconstruction, in which the animator Luc Chamberland hand-drew about two hundred missing drawings, and it premiered that year at the Annecy festival.

Why it matters

It is the earliest animated film to feature a dinosaur. It was not the earliest animated film, though it is often wrongly called that. Blackton and Cohl had made animated films before McCay.

It gave a drawing a character. The Public Domain Review calls it the first cartoon to feature a character with an appealing personality, and Donald Crafton, the historian, writes that McCay imbued her with one. She breathes, shifts her weight and cries, while earlier "trick films" had been about the trick.

It shaped the people who followed. Walt Disney is among the animators who have said that McCay's vaudeville act inspired them, and the film was chosen for the National Film Registry in 1991.

It is free to see. The film is in the public domain in the United States, and McCay died on 26 July 1934. Modern restorations and the music added to them are another matter.

On the same programme

Some of these films are rooms you can play

These notes come from Reel Trouble, a comedy platformer through film history. Every room in it is a movie set, built from scratch as a parody of a real film, and a fall is never a death: it is a retake.

Free, in a desktop browser or as a download for Windows, Mac and Linux.

Quick answers

Was Gertie the Dinosaur the first animated film?

No. Earlier animators, including J. Stuart Blackton and Émile Cohl, had made animated films, and McCay had made two himself. Gertie is the earliest animated film to feature a dinosaur.

Who made Gertie the Dinosaur?

Winsor McCay, a newspaper cartoonist known for the strip Little Nemo in Slumberland. A young neighbour, John Fitzsimmons, helped by tracing the backgrounds.

How many drawings are in Gertie the Dinosaur?

The framing story of the cinema version says ten thousand. Careful historians think that figure suspect, but all agree it took thousands of drawings on thin paper.

What was the Gertie vaudeville act?

McCay stood by the screen with a whip, spoke to Gertie and gave her commands, and she seemed to obey. At the end he walked off stage and reappeared on screen, where Gertie carried him away.

Is Gertie the Dinosaur in the public domain?

Yes, in the United States. The National Film Board of Canada also describes it as public domain. McCay died in 1934. A modern restoration or a recorded score can have rights of its own.

Why did John Bray sue Winsor McCay?

Bray had patented several animation techniques that he had seen McCay use, and he sued McCay in 1914. By the usual account the suit failed, and McCay later received royalties for licensing the techniques to Bray.

Is Gertie the Dinosaur in the National Film Registry?

Yes. It was chosen for the Library of Congress's National Film Registry in 1991.

Did Winsor McCay really bet that he could animate a dinosaur?

Only in the film. The story of a dinner wager with fellow cartoonists belongs to the live-action prologue of the cinema version and is treated as part of the film's fiction, not as a record of events.

Sources and further reading

  1. Gertie the Dinosaur, Wikipedia, for the dates, the act, the prologue, the Bray suit and the Registry year
  2. Winsor McCay, Wikipedia, for the strip, the earlier films, the Hearst contract and his death
  3. Gertie the Dinosaur (1914), The Public Domain Review, 2011
  4. Resurrecting Gertie the Dinosaur, National Film Board of Canada blog, 2019, on the surviving film and the 2018 reconstruction
  5. Gertie the Dinosaur, Encyclopedia.com, on the paper, the split system and the cycles
  6. The Lost World is 100 Years Old and Still Roaring, Library of Congress, Now See Hear! blog, 2025, on Gertie's place in the National Film Registry (1991)
  7. Restoring a Piece of 20th Century Popular Culture, University of Notre Dame Research, 2017, on the stage act, the techniques and the nitrate decay

The audience is on its way

Now play the films

Reel Trouble is a comedy platformer where every room is a movie set, from 1896 on. The free demo has six rooms, a secret room and a premiere.

Free · Desktop: browser, Windows, Mac, Linux · Played with a keyboard